Vintage Diamond Rings Setting: What to Know Before You Buy

“What is the best diamond ring to give to a girl?” is the typical question that most men ask when they are planning to buy a diamond ring for their partner for their engagement. 

There are a lot of considerations when looking for the best rings on the market. It includes the diamond’s size, shape, color, and brilliance. Besides that, you also have to consider your partner’s preference when buying one.

One of the best diamond ring designs that your girl might appreciate is the vintage style.

In this review, you will learn some samples of the best vintage diamond rings, how to pick the best one with great value, and whether the vintage-setting is the right ring for her. 

Top 7 Best Vintage Diamond Rings Reviewed

  1. Blue Nile Braid Halo Solitaire 1.08-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold – Best Overall
  2. Blue Nile Braided Cathedral Solitaire 1.20-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold – Best Value
  3. James Allen Regal Frame 2.01-Carat Asscher-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold – Editor’s Choice
  4. Blue Nile Monique Lhuillier Realeza Three-Stone Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum
  5. Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 2.0-Carat Round Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold
  6. James Allen Vintage Infinity 1.2-Carat Princess-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold
  7. James Allen Beaded Filigree Cathedral Kite-Set 1.09-Carat Marquise-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold

#1. Blue Nile Braid Halo Solitaire 1.08-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold – Best Overall

Blue Nile Braid Halo Solitaire 1.08-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold

Specifications:

  • Carat weight: 1.08
  • Clarity grade: SI2
  • Cut grade: Ideal
  • Color grade: J
  • Metal: 14-karat white gold

According to a survey, Americans spend 1000 USD to 5000 USD for an engagement ring. That is why you will love the Blue Nile Braid Halo Solitaire 1.08-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold because it offers a quality value at an excellent price. 

Looking at the diamond’s four Cs, it does not offer as much. As you can see, the clarity grade is Sl2, the color grade is J, and the cut grade is Ideal, which is not the highest grade. 

This diamond ring is an excellent choice because it is a round cut diamond. The same cut that Mila Kunis and Brook Shields wear. This diamond shape provides the most brilliance, which is the reason for its popularity. Also, the Ideal clarity grade, although not the best cut grade on Blue Nile’s shop, is next to the best, adding to the round-cut diamond’s radiance. 

Because it exudes radiance, it can hide the imperfections, such as the yellowish tinge and inclusions that might be visible to the naked eye. 

The Braid Halo Solitaire design exudes the strength and beauty that you can see in each ring angle. The braid motif adds texture that complements the diamond’s beauty. 

What makes this diamond even better is that it is affordable for most people. This diamond ring will cost you less than 4,000 USD.  

ProsCons
Braid Halo Solitaire design adds texture
Color grade is least of the near-colorless grade
Brilliance hides the imperfections
Affordable
Ideal cut

#2. Blue Nile Braided Cathedral Solitaire 1.20-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold – Best Value

Blue Nile Braided Cathedral Solitaire 1.20-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold

Specifications:

  • Carat weight: 1.20
  • Clarity grade: SI2 
  • Cut grade: Very Good
  • Color grade: I
  • Metal: 14-karat rose gold 

The Blue Nile Braided Cathedral Solitaire 1.20-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold is your next choice if you are looking for another quality diamond ring at a great value. What makes this diamond ring different from the previous one is the cut shape. This diamond ring is also more expensive than the previous one, and this one has a larger diamond, which makes this ring reasonable for its price.

It is a radiant-cut diamond, the same diamond shape that Drew Barrymore wears. This cut exudes brilliance, which is also capable of hiding the diamond’s flaws. 

Although it is more expensive than the previous one, it is affordable for most people, because it will only cost you more than 4,000 USD. If you look at the four Cs, you will see that the grades are better. Although this one is a step down from the previous one’s ideal cut, it can still provide much brilliance. 

The diamond’s color grade is a step higher than the previous one, and the diamond is also larger. 

The 14-karat rose gold provides a beautiful contrast to the diamond. The cathedral-style puts the diamond at the pedestal so that it can shine at its best. The braid motif gives interest by adding texture to the ring. 

ProsCons
Ring design allows the diamond to shine at its maximum brilliance
The cut grade is not the best
Affordable for many people
Textured design
Radiant-cut
1.20-carat

#3. James Allen Regal Frame 2.01-Carat Asscher-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold – Editor’s Choice

James Allen Regal Frame 2.01-Carat Asscher-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold

Specifications:

  • Carat weight: 2.01
  • Clarity grade: VS2
  • Cut grade: n/a
  • Color grade: H
  • Metal: 14-karat white gold 

If you want a large piece of diamond to adorn your engagement ring, take a look at the James Allen Regal Frame 2.01-Carat Asscher-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold. Because the size is directly proportional to the carat, this diamond is more expensive than the two previous rings because of its 2.01-carat weight. 

It is not as expensive as Mary-Kate Olsen’s 81,000-dollar ring, but it is expensive enough to make your girl’s jaw drop.  

It is an Asscher-cut diamond ring, the same diamond cut that Jessica Alba wears. 

Do not expect much brilliance about this cut because it is made with a step-cut, not a brilliance-cut. Because of this, inclusions and flaws are easy to notice. 

However, the diamond’s H-color grade and VS2 clarity grade are already enough for a great value. The H-color grade is a near-colorless grade. You can only notice its inferiority when you compare it with other diamonds with higher grades. 

Although the VS2 clarity grade indicates that a diamond has inclusions, these imperfections are difficult to see at 10x magnification, much more for a naked eye. 

The Regal Frame ring has a bold and romantic design. It has a cathedral shank adorned with pave-set stones that frame the 2.0-carat diamond. 

ProsCons
No visible inclusions to the naked eye
Expensive
Does not exude much brilliance
Almost-colorless diamond
Elaborate ring design
Large diamond
ALSO READ:  Top 7 Best Yellow Diamond Rings | 2021 Reviews + Guide

#4. Blue Nile Monique Lhuillier Realeza Three-Stone Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum

Blue Nile Monique Lhuillier Realeza Three-Stone Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum

Specifications:

  • Carat weight: 1.34
  • Clarity grade: IF
  • Cut grade: Astor Ideal
  • Color grade: D
  • Metal: platinum 

If you care about perfection more than the ring’s price, you might appreciate the Blue Nile Monique Lhuillier Realeza Three-Stone Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum. 

When it comes to the diamond’s four Cs, you will see that this ring is almost perfect. 

The carat weight is the average size for an engagement ring. 

The cut grade is Astor Ideal, the Blue Nile’s highest and signature cut grade. Also, its shape adds to the diamond’s brilliance. 

The clarity grade is internally flawless, which is next to the highest flawless clarity grade. Even though it is not the best grade, this diamond’s clarity quality is still rare. The inclusions are not visible and are only external. 

The D-color grade is the highest of the colorless grade. 

Because of this, it is not surprising that it is expensive. 

This Monique Lhuillier ring design is also perfect for this diamond because of the milgrain-trimmed diamonds that decorate the ring’s band until they reach the center diamond. The twin stones frame the center ring for additional sparkle.  

ProsCons
Monique Lhuillier ring design Expensive
No visible internal inclusions
Highest colorless grade
Astor Ideal cut

#5. Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 2.0-Carat Round Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold

Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 2.0-Carat Round Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold 

Specifications:

  • Carat weight: 2.00
  • Clarity grade: Fl
  • Cut grade: Ideal
  • Color grade: D
  • Metal: 14-karat rose gold 

If Blue Nile Monique Lhuillier Realeza Three-Stone Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in Platinum is not perfect enough for you, Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 2.0-Carat Round Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold might. 

Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 2.0-Carat Round Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold has a 2.00-carat diamond with excellent color, cut, and clarity grades. 

Like the previous one, the ring’s diamond also has the highest colorless grade, but this one has a flawless clarity grade. You will never see a hint of inclusion in the diamond. 

Although the diamond is not Astor Ideal cut, the Ideal cut grade is still a high-quality one. Besides that, it is a round-cut diamond that exudes the best brilliance more than any other shape. 

The  Heirloom Petite Milgrain ring is vintage with two pave-set round-cut diamonds with a milgrain edge that surrounds it. 

Because this ring has better quality than the previous one, this ring is more expensive. 

ProsCons
No visible inclusions even at 10x magnification
Expensive
Almost perfect qualities
Highest colorless grade
Large diamond
Ideal cut

#6. James Allen Vintage Infinity 1.2-Carat Princess-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold

James Allen Vintage Infinity 1.2-Carat Princess-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold

Specifications:

  • Carat weight: 1.2
  • Clarity grade: SI1
  • Cut grade: Ideal
  • Color grade: H
  • Metal: 18-karat white gold

James Allen Vintage Infinity 1.2-Carat Princess-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold is your best choice if you want 18-karat white gold for your diamond, instead of 14. 

The ring has a bold and romantic design. It has a cathedral shank and a set of stones that frame the center diamond. 

The center diamond has a good quality. It is a princess-cut diamond, which is the same shape that Hilary Duff wears. It provides excellent brilliance that can hide the possible flaws. 

The color grade and clarity grade are not the best, but good enough. The H-color grade is near-colorless. You can only notice its inferiority if you compare it with other diamonds with higher grades.

The Sl1 clarity grade is good enough for a princess-cut ring. The inclusions are only visible at 10x magnification but hard to see to the naked eye unless you have a trained eye. The diamond’s ideal cut grade and shape can provide much brilliance, which can hide these inclusions.  

ProsCons
Cheaper than the cost of average diamond ringsRing’s design overpowers the diamond
Brilliance hides the flaws

#7. James Allen Beaded Filigree Cathedral Kite-Set 1.09-Carat Marquise-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold

James Allen Beaded Filigree Cathedral Kite-Set 1.09-Carat Marquise-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold

Specifications:

  • Carat weight: 1.09
  • Clarity grade: SI2
  • Cut grade: n/a
  • Color grade: J
  • Metal: 14-karat rose gold

If you think that the mentioned diamond rings are expensive for you, consider the James Allen Beaded Filigree Cathedral Kite-Set 1.09-Carat Marquise-Cut Diamond Ring in Rose Gold. This ring will cost you less than 3,000 USD, which does not sacrifice quality.

If you look at the diamond’s four Cs, you might probably say that they are not the best. The clarity grade is SI2, indicating that there might be inclusions visible. The color grade is J, indicating that the diamond has a faint color. 

Even though it seems like the diamond is not perfect, its brilliance and the ring’s rose gold composition can hide these flaws.  

This diamond is a marquise-cut, the same diamond shape that Catherine Zeta-Jones wears. It exudes enough brilliance to hide the inclusions. 

The Rose Gold Beaded Filigree Cathedral Kite-Set compensates for the faint yellowish color that this diamond may have. The ring’s elaborate design does not overpower the marquise-cut diamond but instead complements its shape. 

The ring is a combination of romantic and modern design. 

ProsCons
14-karat rose gold hides the diamond’s faint color
N/a
The ring complements the marquise-cut diamond
Affordable

Top Pick – Our Favorite Vintage Diamond Rings

On average, Americans buy an engagement ring worth 1000 USD to 5000 USD, and 11 percent prefer to buy less than 900 USD. It only means that although it is easy to identify which the best diamond rings are, in terms of quality, people still choose to buy diamonds with ok or good-enough quality.

Diamonds are expensive. That is why it is only practical to buy a diamond ring where the price is within one’s budget but still has a good-enough quality. One of these diamond rings’ best examples is Blue Nile Braid Halo Solitaire 1.08-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold. 

This diamond ring does not have the best qualities when you look at the 4-C grades. However, it is good enough and affordable enough because it will only cost you less than 4,000 USD. 

The clarity and color grades are not the best, but because of its ideal cut grade and round shape, this ring is still pleasant to look at. 

It is because the diamond exudes much brilliance that can hide the diamond’s flaws. 

Besides that, this ring’s braided design adds to its beauty, giving some texture and interest.  


Best Vintage Diamond Rings Brands 

Two leading brands come to mind when it comes to online jewelry shops: James Allen and Blue Nile. These brands have a high reputation in the industry, which can be proven by their customers and major online retailers that trust them. 

One of the reasons for their success in the industry is the features that they have on their website. They allow simple navigation and close-up 360-degree view in most of their products so that you can expect the ring as closely as possible. 

Knowing these brands, you know that you can search for more diamond ring designs and styles even though you cannot choose anything from the mentioned ones. 

James Allen

James Allen takes pride in the way it revolutionized online shopping for diamond rings. It claims to be the first shop to provide real-time diamond inspection services. It also claims to be the only retailer to provide a 360-degree HD magnified view of its more than 200,000 products. 

This company won the Bizrate’s Circle of Excellence in 2018. It also manufactures for large online retailers, such as Tiffany & Co. Because of this, you can trust that this company is highly reputable. 

Four people with combined 60 years of experience in the industry collaborated to establish James Allen in 2006. These people are Oded Edelman, Dean Lederman, Michele Sigler, and James Schultz. 

James Allen has three offices in the US: New York, Maryland, and Washington DC.

This company lives under the mission to offer a wide selection of diamonds of the best quality at the best price. 

Blue Nile

Blue Nile has made an excellent reputation in the industry. The company made it in Time Magazine when it became the best Website for Business and received the ‘Best Indulgence’ title. Besides that, it also became 1 of the few that received the Circle of Excellence Platinum Award from Bizarre.com. 

Blue Nile started in the industry when Mark Vadon bought the 85 percent share of the company where he bought his engagement ring. He revolutionized the company’s website. In 1999, he changed its name to Blue Nile. 

Blue Nile works under its philosophy of putting its customers first by offering diamonds and jewelry of the best quality at a great value.


What Is a Vintage Diamond Ring Setting?

From the word vintage, you can already tell that this setting has an antique design. It got its inspiration from Art Deco, Victorian, and Edwardian eras. This set features intricate and elaborate designs that use filigree and milgrain techniques to design the metal details.

These intricate details make the ring eye-catching and non-traditional. It gives jewelry a vintage look, making it an excellent family heirloom ring. 

This ring setting is ideal for those who want a nice engagement ring, which you can pass down to generations. It is also for those people who are looking for perfect and timeless design. 

The only problem with this ring setting is that it is difficult to clean and maintain because of the crevices and details. If you choose the wrong design, it may not work well with the diamond by diverting people’s eyes away from the center stone. 

Besides that, if you acquire a ring with an actual vintage setting, it needs more expertise and time to maintain the gemstone’s secure hold. 

Examples of celebrities who wear rings with a vintage setting are Mila Jovovich, Mary-Kate Olsen, and Ashlee Simpson.


Factors to Consider When Buying the Best Vintage Diamond Rings

The following considerations will let you know if a vintage diamond ring is the best choice for your partner.

Gemstone

The best center stone for the ring does not have to be a diamond. You can determine what it is by observing or knowing your partner’s favorite gemstone. After knowing what it is, it does not mean that you should already head on to the shop and buy it. You also have to assess if it will make the best gemstone for an engagement ring.

The best diamond alternatives are sapphire, ruby, emerald, and other gemstones that last for a long time. The bad choices are pearl, opal, amethyst, and other fragile stones. 

If you intend to buy a diamond ring, assess its shape and the four Cs, which stand for color, carat, cut, and clarity. By knowing how to balance these aspects, you will acquire the best diamond ring at the best price. 

For example, a round-cut diamond exudes the best brilliance. If it has an excellent Ideal cut grade, it will exude much brilliance. Because of it, you can choose a diamond with lower color and clarity grades to get the best value. The diamond’s brilliance can hide the unpleasant qualities of the stone. 

Also, note that the diamond’s size is directly proportional to its carat weight and price. Although many factors can determine a diamond ring’s price, the carat weight is the major determinant. 

It does not mean that the bigger is always better. The bigger the diamond is, the more obvious the imperfections are.

Ring Size

Although you can always resize the diamond ring, you do not want to waste more time and effort, adding the diamond’s resizing to your problems after the proposal. You want your whole attention to be on the preparation for the wedding day. 

That is why you must have to know your partner’s ring size even before shopping for an engagement ring. 

There are a few ways to know your partner’s finger size. You can either borrow a ring from her or tie a string around her finger while sleeping.

Setting

Although the vintage setting is a gorgeous design and will make an excellent family heirloom ring, it is not the best option for all lifestyles. 

If your girl loves getting her hands dirty, such as working in the kitchen or painting, the vintage setting may not be the best choice unless she is willing to take it off. Dirt might get trapped into the crevices and tiny spaces of the ring’s elaborate design, making the cleaning difficult.

A vintage setting requires maintenance and care. It needs attention. Your girl has to make sure that the prongs and details are of their best quality to ensure the gemstone’s secure hold. Therefore, it is not the best choice for girls with an extremely active lifestyle. 

Metal

You also have to observe the right metal construction of the ring. Besides aesthetics, you also have to assess if the metal you choose will make the ring’s overall look.

You can also acquire a great value on a diamond by choosing the right metal. If you choose right, it can hide the faint color of a diamond. For example, you can select up to H-color grade for a marquise-cut ring if you combine it with white gold. You can select even a lower grade of up to J if you choose yellow or rose gold to combine with it. 

Budget

There is a popular saying that an engagement ring’s cost should be equivalent to the total of your two months’ salary. It is a marketing ploy popularized by Da Beers, and they have become successful in instilling it into everyone’s minds. As a result, the groom is pressured into buying more than what he can afford.

Because it is a marketing ploy, you do not have to follow it. Your love for your partner does not have an equivalent price, and a partner who loves you should appreciate the thought, not the expensiveness of the ring. After all, getting yourself into debt just to get the perfect diamond ring will only drag your girl into it, and it is not the best expression of love.  

Jewelry Store

As much as possible, buy from a reputable jewelry store. Make sure that they have the right documents to sell. Their products should be GIA-graded. 

It is best to find a reputable store that offers a warranty in cases of loss and theft. Ask for the diamond’s certificate when you purchase. 


Conclusion 

The answer to the question, “What is the best diamond ring to give to a girl?” is a ring with the same qualities as the Blue Nile Braid Halo Solitaire 1.08-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring in White Gold. It is because this ring is practical when it comes to aesthetics and affordability.

However, you should also observe your partner’s lifestyle and preference, so you can pick the best style and gemstone that she will appreciate. By doing so and by knowing where to shop and how to pick the best quality diamond ring within your budget, you will get the best diamond ring that will put a smile on your girl’s face.

If your girl loves a vintage-style ring, you can pick one of the mentioned diamond rings on this review based on her preferred style. You can choose from the wide diamond rings selection from famous brands like James Allen and Blue Nile if you cannot pick one in this review. 


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

What Is the Best Diamond Ring?

First, make sure that the diamond ring is authentic. Buy from legit stores and jewelers that can provide you a certificate on your purchase. Second, determine your partner’s lifestyle and jewelry preference. You can pick the best ring design and diamond cut by observing your partner’s jewelry preference. Third, get the right ring size for your partner. Fourth, make sure to get the best quality diamond that is within your price range. Lastly, make sure that the ring’s design complements the diamond. It should not be overpowering that it is already diverting the eyes away from the stone.  

Is the Vintage Diamond Ring Setting the Best Style for My Girl?

It depends on her preference and lifestyle. After observing her jewelry preference and fashion style, and sure that she prefers vintage, you should observe her lifestyle. Note that vintage style rings are hard to clean because of the intricate details and crevices that can garner dirt. If your girl loves getting her hands dirty, the vintage setting might not be a good choice unless she is willing to take the ring off from time to time only to keep it clean. Just make sure to select a vintage-style ring that complements the diamond, not overpowers it. 

Should a Diamond Ring Be Expensive?

De Beers have always been successful in their marketing ploys to make people believe that a diamond ring should be expensive. This company is the one that stated that the price of an engagement ring should be equivalent to the total of your salary for two months. Because of this, the belief that a diamond ring should be expensive is just a marketing strategy. The cost of the diamond ring is not the measurement of your love. Getting into debt just because of it and dragging your girl into debt is not love. 

How to Tell if a Diamond Is Fake?

If you insist on buying from an unknown jewelry store or individual, learning how to differentiate the real diamond from the fake one can be handy. You can use a loupe or magnifier to determine the diamond’s authenticity. If you buy a diamond ring with VS1 clarity grade and below, you should see some inclusions at 10x magnification. You can also drop it into a glass of water. A real diamond should sink because of its high density. A black-light can be used too. Diamonds with fluorescence should exude visible light under black light. 

Related Resources:

ALSO READ:  Top 7 Best Yellow Sapphire Rings | 2021 Reviews + Guide

Shop Online to Save

james allen

Best for Online Shopping

james allen reviews
blue nile logo

Best Selections

blue nile reviews
james allen

Our #1 Recommended Jewelry Store

james allen reviews