Aside from the flowers, wine, and food, you also need to prepare the most important part of the proposal: the engagement ring. You want the ring to fit her finger perfectly, and suit her taste.
You cannot just pick anything when it comes to choosing the best engagement ring. Although your partner might still say ‘yes’ out of love, even when you present her a pull-tab, you do not want to let her expectations down.
You know that your partner deserves the best high-quality ring that you can afford. Find out the best side-stone diamond ring that you can buy today.
Table of Contents
Top 7 Best Side-Stone Diamond Rings Reviewed
- James Allen Baguette 5.01-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold – Best Overall
- Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on Rose Gold – Best Value
- James Allen Chevron Knife-Edge 1.02-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold – Editor’s Choice
- Blue Nile Petite 0.31-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on Yellow Gold
- Blue Nile Luna 3.05-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on Platinum
- Blue Nile Graduated Milgrain 0.25-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on Yellow Gold
- James Allen Beat Accent Pave Trio 0.50-Carat Emerald-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold
#1. James Allen Baguette 5.01-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold – Best Overall
- Carat weight: 5.01
- Cut grade: n/a (radiant-cut)
- Clarity grade: FL
- Color grade: D
- Metal: white gold
If you are looking for a diamond ring with the best quality, no matter what the price is, you will never go wrong with James Allen Baguette 5.01-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold.
This diamond ring has perfect qualities from the stone to the metal.
The carat weight of 5.01 is already huge. Your partner’s jaw will surely drop upon seeing just the size of it.
Aside from that, it is a radiant-cut diamond. It is the ideal cut if you want the diamond to sparkle from all angles. The color and clarity grades are also the best.
The diamond has the highest colorless grade, and it does not have any inclusions inside and out. In other words, this diamond is the epitome of perfection.
As for the metal, it is 14-karat white gold. The tapered baguette decorates each side of the 5.01-carat diamond, framing its beauty and adding to its radiance. It is the design that will last for years. It has high-quality ball prons with a wire basket for a secure hold.
|14-karat white gold||Extremely expensive |
- Carat weight: 1.34
- Cut grade: Astor Ideal
- Clarity grade: IF
- Color grade: D
- Metal: rose gold
If you think James Allen Baguette 5.01-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold is extremely expensive, you can check out the Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on Rose Gold. It is the best choice if you still want an almost perfect diamond ring to give your girl without paying a hundred dollars.
This diamond ring is still expensive, but not as expensive as the previous one.
What makes this ring different from the first one is that this is a round-cut diamond, and it is smaller. The clarity grade is not as perfect as the first one, but this one is internally flawless, rare, and ideal.
Even though it has inclusions, they are not visible on the naked eye and only located on the stone’s external part.
The cut grade is Blue Nile’s Astor Ideal, the highest cut grade rating on the shop.
The rose gold metal is vintage. It also has two pave-set round diamonds with surrounding milgrain edges that add to the diamond’s brilliance and beauty.
|Excellent cut grade||Expensive |
|14-karat rose gold|
#3. James Allen Chevron Knife-Edge 1.02-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold – Editor’s Choice
- Carat weight: 1.02
- Cut grade: True Hearts
- Clarity grade: IF
- Color grade: D
- Metal: white gold
If you think the Blue Nile Heirloom Petite Milgrain 1.34-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on Rose Gold does not suit your partner’s taste, you may consider the James Allen Chevron Knife-Edge 1.02-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold.
This diamond almost has the same qualities as the previous one, except that this one is larger. Like the Blue Nile’s 1.34-carat diamond, this one is also colorless and internally flawless, making this ring one of the best choices on the market.
It also has the best cut grade. If it is Astor Ideal in Blue Nile, the highest cut grade on James Allen is True Hearts, which is the cut grade of this ring’s diamond.
This diamond is complemented by the smaller diamonds on both sides, arranged in chevron shape with tapered knife-edge shank. The ring is crafted from 14-karat white gold, adding to the ring’s overall quality.
|Smaller diamonds on the side add to the center diamond’s brilliance||Expensive |
|Highest cut grade|
- Carat weight: 0.31
- Cut grade: Very Good (radiant-cut)
- Clarity grade: VVS2
- Color grade: E
- Metal: yellow gold
Blue Nile Petite 0.31-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on Yellow Gold is one of the best choices if you are looking for a ring that is not the best in quality but still good enough.
The four Cs grades of this diamond are not the best but are still considered high-quality.
The cut grade is ‘very good,’ which is not the best, but the ring’s radiant-cut compensates for it.
The clarity grade is VVS2. It means that this diamond has inclusions but still not visible enough to the naked eye. At 10x magnification, these inclusions are still difficult to see.
The color grade is E, which is next to the highest colorless grade of a diamond. You can only notice that it is an E-color grade when being compared to the D-grade ones.
The only downside is that the carat weight is less than one, which is smaller than average.
The metal is a good-quality one. The design complements the 0.31 diamond ring, which makes up for its small size. The 14-karat yellow gold creates a nice-looking contrast with the diamond.
Because the diamond may not be the best on the market, it will only cost you more than 1,200 USD.
|Inclusions not visible to the naked eye||Small diamond |
- Carat weight: 3.05
- Cut grade: Ideal
- Clarity grade: IF
- Color grade: D
- Metal: platinum
If you are one of those people who want your partner to feel special by giving her a luxurious engagement ring, Blue Nile Luna 3.05-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on Platinum is your next option. It is not as good as the James Allen Baguette 5.01-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold, but it is lower in price and a high-quality one.
The diamond is larger than average. It has the highest colorless grade, and it is internally flawless, which a rare diamond quality.
This diamond is just an Ideal, next to the Blue Nile’s highest cut grade, the Astor Ideal.
The ring design is exquisite because of its prong-set of diamonds that focus on the large 3.05-carat diamond and adds more shimmer to it.
|Side diamonds add to the center diamond’s shimmer||Small diamond |
|Highest colorless grade|
- Carat weight: 0.25
- Cut grade: Ideal
- Clarity grade: Sl2
- Color grade: H
- Metal: yellow gold
Blue Nile Graduated Milgrain 0.25-Carat Round-Cut Diamond Ring on Yellow Gold is your best choice if you are looking for a diamond ring that is good enough without spending a lot of money. This ring will only cost you more than 1000 USD but do not set a high standard for it.
The diamond’s four Cs’ characteristics are not the best but not bad at all.
The color grade is H, indicating that this diamond is near-colorless. You can only notice its inferiority when compared to the ones with the higher color grades.
The clarity grade is Sl2. The inclusions are only visible at 10x magnification.
The cut grade is ideal, which is not bad because it is next to Blue Niles Astor Ideal cut grade. The Ideal cut can still provide marvelous sparkles in all angles, although not as good as the diamonds with Astor Ideal cut.
The downside is that the carat weight is less than average. It looks small for the fingers.
However, the ring accentuates the ring, directing the eyes to the center diamond. Also, the 14-karat yellow gold gives a nice contrast to it.
|Yellow gold creates a beautiful contrast with the diamond||Small diamond |
|Inclusions visible at 10x magnification|
- Carat weight: 0.50
- Cut grade: n/a
- Clarity grade: Sl2
- Color grade: K
- Metal: white gold
If you think that all the mentioned diamond rings are still expensive, you might want to consider the James Allen Beat Accent Pave Trio 0.50-Carat Emerald-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold. This diamond ring will cost you less than a thousand dollars. However, do not expect much about the diamond’s quality, although it can be good enough.
The diamond’s clarity grade is Sl2, which means that the inclusions are visible at 10x magnification, and you can even see some of these inclusions with the naked eye. It has a slight faint color but still offers a great value.
The diamond’s carat weight is less than the average, but the ring’s design compensates for it because of the pave-set stones on the side, framing the center stone.
|Excellent ring design||Some inclusions are visible to the naked eye. |
|14-karat white gold||Slight faint color |
There are different ring and diamond designs available on the market. It feels overwhelming to choose which one of them is the best. This review aims to reduce your options by presenting you with some of the best samples you can buy from the best brands.
If you want to know the best side-stone diamond ring to buy, this review’s top choice is the James Allen Baguette 5.01-Carat Radiant-Cut Diamond Ring on White Gold. When it comes to the ring’s quality, it is perfection.
The 5.01-cut grade is an unarguably large chunk of diamond that decorates your ring, along with the side stones that frame it. Besides that, the color and clarity are at the highest grades: the color grade is at the highest colorless grade of D, and the clarity grade is flawless. You will not see any inclusions inside and out.
It is a radiant-cut diamond that shimmers in all angles.
Aside from the diamond, the 14-karat white gold ring looks good with this diamond. The side stones complement that center stone well, allowing the eyes to focus on the 5.01-carat ring.
Best Side-Stone Diamond Ring Brands
When it comes to finding high-quality diamonds at great value online, two stores come into mind: The Blue Nile and James Allen.
Both these shops offer a 360-degree view of their products and allow you to design your ring. Even if you cannot find the one that suits your partner’s taste in this review, you can find the perfect ring in one of these brands.
Blue Nile has been in the industry since 1999, when Mark Vadon bought the 85 percent share of a jewelry company he bought an engagement ring from. He changed the company’s website and named it Blue Nile.
This company adheres to its customer-first philosophy because it believes that customers deserve straightforward information, a wide range of diamond selections, and excellent services. Blue Nile wants to offer the best-quality jewelry and diamonds at the best value.
Blue Nile became 1 of the only 20 who have received Bizzare.com’s Circle of Excellence Platinum Award.
The company also made it in the Best Website for Business in Time Magazine, deeming it the “Best Indulgence.”
Four people with combined 60 years of experience founded James Allen in 2006. They are James Schultz, Dean Lederman, Michele Sigler, and Oded Edelman. The company currently has three offices in the US: New York, Washington, DC, and Maryland.
James Allen takes pride in some of their website’s features that revolutionize the way customers shop online. The company claims to be the only retailer to provide a 36-degree HD magnified view to more than 200,000 products. They are also the pioneer of providing real-time diamond inspection services.
James Allen is the manufacturer of many big retailers, such as Tiffany& Co. They also won the Circle of Excellence Award in 2018.
Factors to Consider When Buying a Side-Stone Diamond Ring
If you want the best diamond ring for your girl, you have to make sure that its design is based on your partner’s preference, not yours. However, it does not mean that you can just buy anything that looks like the type of jewelry that your partner likes. You also have to inspect the ring’s quality.
To find out what kind of side-stone diamond ring to buy for your girl, note the following considerations.
Because the diamond commonly takes the biggest part of the budget for the ring and the most important part of it, it has to be your first consideration. You want to make out of its value with the budget that you have.
The first thing to consider when inspecting the diamond’s quality is the four Cs. These four Cs are the criteria that the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) uses to assess the diamond’s characteristics. Because the big institution inspects the four Cs to determine its quality, you should too.
The four Cs stand for color, carat, clarity, and cut.
The assessment of the color ranges from the varying degree of the diamond’s colorlessness to faintness. The highest grade is D, which is the highest colorless grade, and the lowest Z, indicating that the diamond has an obvious faint brown or yellow color.
The carat weight is directly proportional to its size, as well as its price. Even though the color, clarity, and cut grades also affect the diamond’s price, the carat weight is the major determinant.
What has considered the average carat weight for an engagement ring in the US is 1.08-carat.
If the carat weight is high, it does not automatically mean that it is good. Visible inclusions and faint color become more obvious the larger the diamond size is. Because of this, a high-quality 1.0-carat diamond costs less and looks better than an 8.0-carat diamond with visible inclusions and faint color.
The clarity grades describe how many inclusions are present and visible to the naked eye. Flawless is the best quality, although internally flawless is excellent too. Diamonds with either of these quality grades are valuable and rare.
Diamonds with inclusions that are not visible are good enough options.
The cut grades can also be a crucial consideration if the diamond’s brilliance is important to you. The best cut grade is ‘Ideal,’ although there is a better cut grade given by shops. The best cut grade for Blue Nile is Astor Ideal, while it is True Hearts for James Allen.
Aside from the four Cs, it would help if you also consider the diamond’s shape to suit your partner’s personality and preference. For example, a heart-shaped cut is for ladies who are bold and unconventional. Round-cut is for simple girls who prefer practicality and timelessness.
Aside from the diamond, the ring’s setting should be your next consideration. The setting is important because it determines the ring’s strength of hold to the gemstone. You should pick the setting according to your partner’s lifestyle and favorite activities. You should also pick the right setting, not just to the center stone but also to the side stones.
For example, if your partner loves doing messy activities, such as gardening and painting, think twice if a diamond ring with side stones is the best for her. The more side stones the ring has, the more it is difficult to clean. The best setting for this kind of lifestyle is a solitaire prong setting.
If your partner’s profession requires the frequent use of hands, such as a chef, there will be a risk of snagging the gemstone in various places. If your girl is in this kind of profession, select a ring setting with no elevated gemstone. The channel set setting is the most advisable.
Gold, yellow gold, rose gold, and platinum is the typical metal choices. You can choose either of them, although many people prefer platinum more because of its quality that can be better than gold. The downside of it is that it fades over time, but it is polishable.
Trending metal nowadays is rose gold.
Any of these metals will do. You only have to choose the best metal that will go well with the diamond ring’s design and color. For example, the white metal prong goes well with gold.
If you consider a diamond ring with side stones, make sure to get your girl’s finger’s accurate size before heading to the store. There is no room for mistakes and possible future adjustments for rings with side stones because repairing and resizing them will be difficult.
If you want to hide your plans of buying a ring from your girl, there are a few ways that you can determine the ring size of your girl.
You may borrow a ring from her and push it to a lump of clay or soap. You may also refer to the sizing chart available in any jewelry store once you have it. You can also ask a friend to try it on. If it fits, you can take your friend with you the next time you shop for a diamond ring.
You can also tie a string around her ring finger while she is sleeping. Make sure to measure the proper finger because the left hand’s measurement is slightly different from the right hand.
There is a saying that an engagement ring’s cost should be equivalent to the two month’s total of your salary. It is a bluff spread by diamond companies who only want you to bleed for more money.
Your partner will appreciate the thoughts more than the cost of the engagement ring. She will appreciate it more if you can give her a family heirloom ring, and it does not cost a cent.
The bottom line is you should buy the ring that you can afford. Do not get yourself into debt and drag your girl along into it after marriage just to buy the diamond ring of the best quality.
It does not have to be a diamond. You can choose diamond alternatives like sapphire and ruby. However, make sure to choose a durable gemstone. Do not choose soft and brittle gemstones like opal.
Number of Side Stones
The typical choices are the three-stone and five-stone settings.
However, you cannot just guess the number of gemstones to put on the engagement ring. It would be best if you also observe your partner’s lifestyle and design preferences. You also need to consider future maintenance needed.
The more gemstones you add to the ring, the more intricate details will be added. It means that it will require more maintenance and possible future repairs. It also means that more gemstones will be at risk of getting lost when it snags onto something.
Color of the Side Stones
The side stones should be at the same color grade as the center stone. If not, it will not look good to its overall appearance. The color grade difference between the center and the sides stones should be one and not more than that.
Clarity of the Side Stones
Although it is ideal to choose the stones with the best clarity on the market, it will be impossible to buy for most people.
When choosing the best side stones’ clarity, you can go for the ones with up to Sl2 clarity grades. If the side stones are small enough and placed delicately, the inclusions will not be visible to the naked eye.
Size of the Side Stones
When choosing the side stones’ size, you need to consider the ring’s overall balance and design. The side-stones should not dominate the center ring’s size or steal the eyes’ attention away from it.
Note that if the side stones you choose have visible inclusions, there will become more visible the larger the side stones are.
When it comes to picking the best side-stone diamond ring, you need to recognize the considerations.
By knowing your partner’s ring size, lifestyle, and preferences, you will save time, money, and effort. You do not have to go back to the store to resize the ring. You also do not have to worry about the gemstones falling off the ring.
Besides that, you also need to consider the quality and design of the diamond, side stones, metal, and setting. Although a partner might not care if you give her a pull-tab on your proposal, giving her an authentic and beautiful diamond ring will put a smile on her face. It also shows your sincerity because of the money and effort you spent on it.
You can pick one in some of the best diamond side-stone rings samples mentioned or buy from the reputable brands to find more samples.
If you prepare everything on the day of your proposal: from the restaurant to your engagement ring, expect that feeling like winning the lottery when your partner finally says ‘yes.’
FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)
Is the Side-Stone Diamond Ring the Best Style for My Partner
The side-stone is a pave setting where the gemstones like sapphires, rubies, and diamonds are mounted on the shank at both sides of the center diamond. Diamond rings with side-stones cost less than the simple ones with a solitaire setting. If the small gemstones or beads are placed right, these will complement the center stone, adding to its brilliance. It is a perfect ring style if your partner loves wearing jewelry that demands attention. The only problem with this style is that cleaning may be difficult, and intricate care should be observed.
What Is the Best Engagement Diamond Ring?
The best diamond ring should be based on your partner’s preference and lifestyle. It also has the quality that will last a lifetime. The best engagement diamond ring does not have to be the most expensive or the biggest chunk of stone. Buy what you can afford. You can make the most of your purchase if you can find the best quality diamond ring within your budget. By knowing the four Cs of diamonds, you can find the best ring at a great value. If you can make your ring sentimental, the better it will be.
How to Differentiate a Real Diamond From the Fake One?
If you plan to buy from an individual jeweler, you need to learn how to differentiate the real diamond from the fake. You can do it in various ways. You can use a loupe or magnifier. Diamonds with VVS or less clarity grade should have inclusions. It will be difficult to find for VVS1, where inclusions are usually at the bottom half of a diamond. You may also drop a diamond into a glass of water to see if it will sink. Real diamonds should sink because of their high density.