Emerald Cut Diamonds Buying Guide: 2021 Reviews

Emerald Cut Diamonds

The emerald cut diamond is one of the unique cuts that are currently available in the market. There are only roughly 3% of these cuts right now, and this is what makes them so valuable and desirable. And, these are what make them so novel and interesting when seen in jewelry.

Getting these diamond jewelry may seem easy, but since most of the diamonds in the market are sold as loose gemstones, making this choice may look more complicated. But, that’s where you are mistaken. There is a very reliable measure for measuring the quality of these diamonds. And, with that guide, all you need now is to have an idea of which are the best emerald cut diamonds in the market.

Read on to see which are the best emerald cut diamonds available, what to look for, and where to get them. 

Top 7 Best Emerald Cut Diamonds Reviewed

  1. 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Best Overall
  2. 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile –  Best Value
  3. 1.02-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Editor’s Choice
  4. 1.00 Carat Emerald Diamond by James Allen 
  5. 0.35 Carat Emerald Diamond by James Allen
  6. 0.52 Carat Round Diamond by James Allen
  7. 0.52 Carat Round Diamond by Blue Nile

#1. 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Best Overall

placeholder for image player

Specifications:

  • Cut: Very Good
  • Color: D
  • Clarity: FL
  • Carat Weight: 1.00
  • Certification: GIA 

Blue Nile is a well-known online jewelry retailer with a long-standing commitment to consistency and reliability when it comes to providing the best quality gemstones, jewelry, and accessories. Their commitment can be seen in every single piece of jewelry they offer. And, when it comes to elegance, beauty, and perfection, their emerald-cut loose diamonds are top-notch. 

Their collection houses among the best and most highly graded pieces on the market. And, they are the proud retailer of the most amazing emerald-cut diamond out there. It is amazing enough to top the list, as well as the market. 

Their 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond is deserving of the top spot on this list. Not only is it an amazingly cut piece of loose gemstone. Its cut is very well done, and the elegance and beauty it brings to the diamond are phenomenal. It is also very white and deserving of the highly coveted color grade of “D.” It is so clean and free of inclusions that it is considered a flawless stone by expert and certification entities. 

This diamond will be an amazing centerpiece, especially if it’s paired with smaller side diamonds or colored gemstones. You can choose to put this on any jewelry, and it will be just as beautiful as any other option. And if you choose to put this on a ring, no matter your choice of accompanying metals, this diamond will shine brightly and will catch everyone’s attention. 

It is not often that you see a gemstone this beautiful, so taking advantage of the opportunity is important. Besides making for a piece of great jewelry, this will also make for an even more amazing investment. Getting this emerald-cut diamond will be one of the choices you will make.

ProsCons
Precise proportions, polish, and symmetry
Very Expensive
Larger than most others on the market
Colorless and free of inclusions
Great cut, clarity, and clearness
Perfect for engagement rings

#2. 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile –  Best Value

Sample top view of diamond

Specifications:

  • Cut: Very Good
  • Color: D
  • Clarity: IF
  • Carat Weight: 1.00
  • Certification: GIA 

Blue Nile has a huge collection of the best emerald-cut diamonds today. With that size, it means that they also have multiple options of the almost identical loose diamonds. And that means that there will always be a more affordable or more elegant option in their collection for you.

This is another 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond from their collection that can be compared with the top pick on the list. It is also very well cut, and the shine it gives off is amazing. Its color is also deserving of the color grade of “D” as it doesn’t have any coloration at all. The only thing different about it is that this has certain flaws in the outer part of the diamond. Regardless, it is still deserving of an “IF” clarity grade, a step below the top pick.

This loose diamond is the best substitute if you are looking for something that is just as beautiful but is more affordable. It is an amazing option for those who are looking for an eye-perfect diamond but are on a slightly tighter budget. This emerald-cut diamond will make for a great centerpiece for any piece of jewelry, and you won’t even have to break your bank for it.

ProsCons
Precise proportions, polish, and symmetry
A little expensive
Great substitute to the top pick on the list
Larger than most others on the market
Colorless and free of inclusions
Great cut, clarity, and clearness

#3. 1.02-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Editor’s Choice

placeholder for image player

Specifications:

  • Cut: Very Good
  • Color: K
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Carat Weight: 1.00
  • Certification: GIA 

Another option from Blue Nile, this is yet another more affordable option for people who are looking for an emerald-cut diamond for their jewelry.  This 1.02-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile may have its flaws, but it will still be a great addition to any piece of jewelry you put it in.

This is fairly heavy at 1.02 carats and will work as another substitute to the top pick on the list. This may not be the clearest one on the list not is it up there in clarity, but these flaws are what gives it its character. 

This gemstone will also make an amazing centerpiece for any ring or bigger necklaces. And since it’s fairly large, you won’t need to pair it with other gemstones.  It should be able to stand on its own, proudly and magnificently.

This gemstone is a testament to the beauty that doesn’t come for a price. You will not regret it if you choose to get this stone for yourself, nor will you regret putting it on your most favorite jewelry in the future. 

ProsCons
Precise proportions, polish, and symmetryA little expensive
Great substitute to the top pick on the list
Larger than most others on the market
Colorless and free of inclusions
Great cut, clarity, and clearness

#4. 1.00 Carat Emerald Diamond by James Allen

1.00 Carat Emerald Diamond

Specifications:

  • Cut: True Hearts™ 
  • Color: D
  • Clarity: FL
  • Carat Weight: 1.05
  • Certification: GIA 

Another amazing retailer of the best gemstone today is James Allen. They are an amazing online jewelry retailer offering 200,000 individual gemstone pieces from various cuts, colors, clarity, weight, and price. What more, they are the exclusive retailers of the gemstones they offer, and you won’t have to worry about unexpected conflicts when getting any diamond from their collection.

James Allen offers an amazing balance between quality and value. With them, you will, without a doubt, get the best loose diamond that fits you best. And, this is also true for their first entry on this list. Their 1.00 Carat Emerald Diamond is just is simply amazing.

It may not be the biggest gemstone in their collection, but when it comes to matching the best loose emerald-cut diamond on this list, it stands the tallest. It is also very highly rated and boasts perfect ratings across the boards. It has a color grade of “D” and a clarity grade of “FL.” And what sets it apart from the top pick on the list is that it is more affordable. 

James Allen has always been a retailer that has been providing the best quality gemstones at a much more affordable price. And this emerald-cut diamond is a testament to that.

ProsCons
Can be paid for in installmentsA little expensive
Great carat weight and quality
Overall amazing stone
Affordable for its class

#5. 0.35 Carat Emerald Diamond by James Allen

0.35 Carat Emerald Diamond

Specifications:

  • Cut: Very Good
  • Color: F
  • Clarity: VVS2
  • Carat Weight: 0.35
  • Certification: GIA 

There will be times when getting something with some imperfections is what you want. After all, getting something with more character is more desirable.  And, at those times, James Allen’s wide array of budget-friendly options has you covered. 

At first glance, this is not the best-looking emerald-cut diamond on this list, nor is it the highest graded loose stone around, but it’s still a great option for people on a budget. It’s not perfect, but there are times that the mere thought of getting a diamond is satisfaction enough. If you are on a budget, consider getting this one and work your way up the ladder as you go. Making this choice is much better than going leaps and bounds to get something you cannot afford.

Unlike the previous diamonds, this one will not set you back by over $1000. This is because of the presence of some inclusions and its lower carat weight. This may be seen as flaws but, no matter, it’s still a great diamond. It also has a lower color grading of “F,” but this is still considered colorless, so you won’t have to worry about it. 

Regardless of its flaws, you are still guaranteed a great piece out of this diamond. After all, elegance doesn’t necessarily come in big boxes or high prices; it’s all about how you carry it. 

ProsCons
Reasonable for its priceHas noticeable flaws
Color adds character
Very affordable
Great cut

#6. 0.52 Carat Round Diamond by James Allen

0.52 Carat Emerald Diamond

Specifications:

  • Cut: Very Good
  • Color: G
  • Clarity: VS1
  • Carat Weight: 0.35
  • Certification: GIA 

Another emerald-cut diamond from James Allen that will not set you back by a thousand dollars. This is a slightly bigger gemstone from the previous one. This may not be the most breathtaking stone, but the quality it brings on to the table is still amazing.

This may not be as clean, nor is its color as clear, it should still make for an amazing centerpiece for any jewelry you will put it on. You will find some inclusions on this stone when you look at it under magnification, but that’s what happens when getting something cheaper. It also has a slight tinge of color, but not too much that is too noticeable. 

Getting this instead of the others on the list is something you will not regret, nor will it go unappreciated when you give it to your special someone. After all, in the end, all diamonds are the same. What sets them apart is not their grade, but how much you are willing to love and cherish them. The true value of these stones is completely dependent on you.

ProsCons
Reasonable for its priceHas noticeable flaws
Color adds character
Very affordable
Great cut

#7. 0.52 Carat Round Diamond by Blue Nile

placeholder for image player

Specifications:

  • Cut: Very Good
  • Color: G
  • Clarity: VS1
  • Carat Weight: 0.35
  • Certification: GIA 

Now, something a little more grand and luxurious. It is no secret that bigger is better, and that is true for diamonds as well. Just look at this stunning piece, it may not follow the societal norms of what makes an amazing emerald piece, but it still embodies the beauty and grandeur that comes with the shape.

This gemstone embodies beauty and luxury. With the polish’s excellence and the unusual length to width ratio of the diamond, this is an incredibly unique diamond. It has amazing color and clarity. With flawless clarity and a near-perfect white color, there is not much you’d ask for in this piece.

This is incredibly large at 3 carats, and this makes it valuable and expensive. Had it been possible for emerald-cut diamonds to be included in the Blue Nile Astor collection, this diamond will surely be in there. It is deserving of a spot on the collection simply because of its beauty, totally deserving of the distinction of being a part of the top 1% of the best diamond all over the world.

But, what sets it apart from everything else is that it doesn’t come in the usual rectangular shape. This diamond’s length and width ratio are almost equal to one, making it more square. Regardless, it still has the signature bevels you can see on the emerald-cut diamonds.

This emerald-cut head-turner will take the attention of every person in the room. It may not come at an affordable price, but luxury is an investment. And, this diamond is the peak of luxury for emerald-cut diamonds. It could have topped the list had it been more affordable. Regardless, it deserves its spot on the list and is in a totally separate class of its own. 

ProsCons
Elegant and sophisticated shine
Very expensive
Perfect length and width ratio
Perfect for engagement rings
Great details and colorless
Unconventional shape

Top Pick Section

The 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile is deserving of the top spot on this list. It is undeniably the best emerald-cut diamond on the market today. Its quality and beauty may not be the highest on the list, but the balance of these two factors that it offers is top-notch.

And, since it comes from Blue Nile, you are guaranteed to get the same commitment they pride themselves in. A commitment to being a consistent and reliable retailer of the best quality gemstones, jewelry, and accessories in the world.

This diamond’s cut is very well done, and the elegance and beauty the cut brings to the diamond are phenomenal. It is also very white and deserving of the highly coveted color grade of “D.” It is so clean and free of inclusions that it is considered a flawless stone by expert and certification entities.

This loose gemstone is guaranteed to be an amazing centerpiece for any jewelry you will pair it with. The characteristics that it can boast are too amazing to pass on, and it’s highly recommended that you add this emerald-cut diamond to your collection.


What Are Emerald Cut Diamonds

The emerald cut is among the unique shape for diamonds that is currently available in the market. This shape only makes up about 3% of all the processed diamonds in the world. 

The name of this cut comes from the fact that the cut was traditionally used for emeralds, a popular green gemstone with exquisite beauty. This shape has since been adopted to provide a new twist on the older and more common cuts, such as round and cushion, for these diamonds. Nowadays, the emerald-cut is enjoying a surge in popularity, and more and more people want to get their own.

What makes the emerald-cut popular is that you can get a similar-sized emerald-cut diamond, with the same carat weight, at a more affordable price. This isn’t true for all cuts of diamonds, especially for the more popular round brilliant cuts. This is because of the easier method of cutting diamonds into this shape, and there is usually no difference in size regardless of the gemstone’s carat weight. 


Where to Get the Best Emerald-Cut Diamonds

Blue Nile

Blue Nile is an amazing place to get your gemstone and jewelry fix. Among the most tried and tested online retailers of the best diamond pieces, they have grown into one of the most reliable sources of the best gemstones and jewelry in the world since they started in 1999.

Their values are dictated by their desire to educate their clients more about diamonds and jewelry. They want their clients to understand how to get the best diamonds before they finalize their purchases with them. And, this commitment to their clients is what gives them an edge in this industry. 

They also offer a great way for them and their clients to connect to them. They have the best customer service lines today, and they are more than ready and willing to attend to your concerns, may they be big or small.

James Allen

James Allen was founded by people passionate about great service and providing people with the best pieces of jewelry. They are jewelry enthusiasts invested in innovating the ways people satisfy their cravings for pieces of jewelry. Nowadays, they are the crème-de-la-crème retailer of affordable and high-quality gemstones and jewelry.

James Allen is not like other online jewelry stores. They have thousands upon thousands of customizable loose gemstones that you can choose from and make into your very own pieces. Their products are hand-picked and ethically sourced. They also feature an amazing 360° Diamond Display Technology on their website that you can utilize to preview the product they offer. 


What are the 4Cs

The quality of diamonds is based on four factors. These four factors are more commonly known as the 4Cs. These include a diamond’s Carat, Color, Clarity, and Cut. Each of these criteria has its grading scale, and the higher the overall average of a diamond is based on these criteria, the more valuable it is. 

These criteria guide experts and their customers when they are looking for the best diamonds in the market. These 4Cs have been used for years now, and the value of these criteria has not wavered since.

Here are the 4Cs, what each of these means, and what you want grade you want your diamond to be:

Carat

Most people have this misconception that a diamond’s carat is a measure of its size, but they are a weight measure. Hence, the term “carat weight.” These diamonds are also measured in points, and 100 points are equal to 1 carat. 

If you are looking to cut costs when buying diamond pieces, it is recommended that you look for a diamond that has .10 or .15 carats less than the one you are looking for. The best diamond pieces are not necessarily the ones with the highest carat weight, especially not emerald-cut diamonds. 

You can even opt to get something lighter for this cut, and you will still end up with an identical piece. The difference in these is barely noticeable to the naked eye, and you will still get the look that you want from your diamond. 

Color

Diamonds come in several colors, from white, yellow, pink, blue, you name it. Traditionally, whiter diamonds are valued higher than colored ones, but this trend is getting stale, and more and more people are opting for colored diamonds.

The diamonds that get a “D” grade are considered “colorless,” and they are the rarest and most expensive. These “colorless” grade diamonds extend from “D” to “F.” And, this grading metric has 23 levels, and each level down introduces more color to the diamond. Most diamonds in the market are graded at the usual “J-D.” After these grades, the colors become more noticeable even for the naked eye. 

Clarity

Diamonds are natural gemstones, and everything from nature is bound to have flaws. Like any gemstone or mineral, diamonds often contain flaws, called inclusions and blemishes. Some of these can be seen by the naked eye, while some are can only be seen through magnification. 

These flaws are not always easily seen, and most jewelers work around them when cutting them to increase the diamond’s clarity. And, after the SI2 grade, these flaws are barely noticeable to the untrained eye. 

It would be recommended that you choose a diamond that is as eye-clean as possible, but also remembers that the inclusions are what gives these gemstones their uniqueness and character. Regardless of your choice, most seasoned jewelers will position the gemstone onto your jewelry in a way that hides these inclusions and blemishes as much as possible.

Cut

The cut of the diamond is much more difficult to quantify than the other Cs. This is because the cut so variable, and it is ultimately up to the jeweler to decide how to cut the diamond. Regardless, this is the most noticeable factor that you consider when getting a diamond.

Unlike the previous Cs, there are a few other things considered when grading the cut of the diamond.

Brightness

The ability of the diamond to reflect light.

Fire

The way light spreads and scatters throughout the diamond creates a rainbow of light, much like a prism does.

Scintillation

The amount and intensity of the sparkle or flashes that occur in the diamond while it moves and light hits it differently. 


Taking Care of Your Diamond Jewelry

Diamonds rank as the hardest minerals in the Mohs scale. They are extremely tough and can take a beating. These diamonds are even used to cut other gemstones as they are much tougher than them. The industrial uses of diamonds are very wide and differing, making for a great testament to just how hard and tough diamonds are. 

They are excellent for everyday wear jewelry, and you wouldn’t have to worry about damaging them even if you hit a corner or accidentally scratch it. However, the same cannot be said for the metals that they are attached to. 

This means that cleaning them will be more of a consideration of the metals than the diamonds.  These metals can be damaged by contacts with certain cleaning solutions, harder chemicals, and contact with other metals, but the diamond will not be affected. 

This is why it is recommended to clean these diamonds using mellow cleaning agents such as dishwashing soap and a brush instead of chemicals. When doing this, Use a soft brush and gently brush at the back of the gemstone where dust usually accumulates and quickly rinse with water shortly after. It is also safe to use ultrasonic cleaners for these diamonds. 

But, regardless of its toughness and durability, it is always wiser to avoid wearing these jewelry pieces at the beach or in the pool, where they are more prone to slipping off. It is also not recommended that you have these when you are doing strenuous activities such as going to the gym or manual labor.


Conclusion

The struggle of the best emerald-cut diamond that will fit your criteria is difficult. Making this decision will require you to understand what makes for a great diamond and what the makings of a great emerald-cut gemstone are. 

Aside from the different options in the market, you also have to look foot that perfectly balanced loose gemstone that will easily fit your needs. And, this is more difficult than simply looking at a store and picking it out. But, that is exactly why this list of the best emerald-cut diamond on the market was created. 

There are several great choices in the market today, and the one that has the best balance between shape, specifications, size, carat weight, and the cost is the top pick on this list. The 1.00-Carat Emerald Cut Diamond by Blue Nile is everything you want from the perfect emerald-cut diamond. It may be slightly expensive, but it’s a price you will have to pay to get the quality gemstones on the market.

If you ever find that any of these loose diamonds are not worthy of being added to your collection, then you can always choose to look for one by yourself. And, when this happens Blue Nile, and James Allen has you covered. They offer an easy way of finding the best loose diamonds out there.

Regardless of your choice, hopefully, after reading this list, it helped you make your choice and that you will get an amazing emerald-cut diamond gemstone that will make any jewelry you will own more beautiful.


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

What is a diamond?

Diamonds are crystals made up of carbon atoms that are naturally arranged in an isometric pattern or cubic matrix.  These different encounter amounts of heat and pressure, and these are what affect their growth. The gemstone’s resulting characteristics are what determines the color, shape, and clarity of the diamond.

What does a diamond mean?

Others believe that they are a promise of a lasting and enduring romance when they are given as gifts for your significant other. At the same time, others think that they are gemstones associated with inner peace and insist that they represent harmony and beauty, both in appearance and personality.

Can you customize your jewelry with Blue Nile and James Allen?

Yes. Both of their websites allow you to customize the jewelry that will come with the loose diamond gemstone of your choice. Since both of them are committed to giving you the jewelry of your dreams, they provide you with more options that will allow you to choose the different factors you need to consider when getting these pieces of jewelry. They both also offer amazing customer support that can help you make your choices.

Related Resources:

Learn More in Our Related Articles

Shop Online to Save

james allen
james allen reviews

OUR #1 RATED ONLINE JEWELRY STORE

james allen
james allen reviews

Shop Online to Save

james allen
james allen reviews