Top 10 Best Orange Diamonds | 2021 Reviews + Guide

Best Orange Diamonds

Orange is an uncommon color in the world of fancy-colored diamonds. These gems are intriguing, alluring, and highly valued among diamond enthusiasts and jewelry collectors. Also known as fire or pumpkin diamonds, natural orange diamonds are among the rarest and one-of-a-kind variety of the fancy-colored diamond family. 

Orange diamonds are often sourced from the Argyle Mine in South Africa and Western Australia. They acquire their gorgeous hue to the nitrogen element, just as yellow diamonds. The only difference between orange and yellow diamonds is how nitrogen atoms are formed during their creation process.

Orange diamonds come with secondary tones, such as pink, yellow, brown, which are often offered in several jewelry stores. However, there are also vivid, pure orange stones, one of the most valuable gems in the jewelry marketplace.  

This diamond buying guide will show you the best orange diamonds available in the market at different hues, intensities, cuts, and price. The selections you will find focus on the two leading online jewelry retailers: Blue Nile and James Allen. You will also learn the factors to consider when buying an orange diamond to make a worthwhile investment.

So before you start your diamond shopping, let this guide show you how to buy the best orange diamonds.

Top 10 Best Orange Diamonds Reviewed

  1. 1.18-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Radiant Diamond by James Allen – Best Overall
  2. 0.43-Carat Vivid Yellow-Orange Cushion Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Best Value
  3. 0.46-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Heart Diamond by James Allen – Editor’s Choice
  4. 1.20-Carat Deep Brownish Orange Round Diamond by Blue Nile
  5. 0.19-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Oval Diamond by James Allen
  6. 0.50-Carat Deep Yellowish Orange Radiant Cut Diamond by Blue Nile
  7. 0.31-Carat Fancy Intense Orange Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen
  8. 0.83-Carat Intense Yellow-Orange Pear Shaped Diamond by Blue Nile
  9. 0.31-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Pear Diamond by James Allen
  10. 0.66-Carat Deep Brownish Orange Oval Diamond by Blue Nile

#1. 1.18-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Radiant Diamond by James Allen – Best Overall

1.18 Carat Radiant Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 1.18 carats
  • Shape: Radiant
  • Color: Fancy vivid yellowish-orange
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Polish: Very good
  • Measurement: 6.14 x 5.57 mm

Looking for a hot, new item for your jewelry collection? The 1.18-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Radiant Diamond by James Allen is a gorgeous diamond gem that appears as if it is on a blazing fire. This GIA-certified diamond with SI2 clarity has a truly one-of-a-kind color with a stunning pumpkin color saturation. 

This orange diamond has a very good polish and good symmetry. A cross between the cushion and princess cut, this gem has a square shape with eight corners. It gives off a stylish and elegant appearance, which can be quite rare to find in most jewelry shops. Its standout feature is its unique, deep cut that maximizes its color refraction with a highly brilliant luster. 

This blazing orange diamond stone is a perfect choice for an engagement ring that sparkles with fire and brilliance. With its carefully beveled corners, this diamond has substantial durability against breakage and chips, perfect for ladies who have an active lifestyle. 

ProsCons
Offers extra presence when mounted on orange diamond rings
Less sparkle than round cuts
Larger perceived size than other cuts
Poor flashes of colored light
Ideal for investmentNot versatile enough
Better durability

#2. 0.43-Carat Vivid Yellow-Orange Cushion Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Best Value

0.43-Carat Vivid Yellow-orange Cushion Cut Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.43 carats
  • Shape: Cushion
  • Color: Vivid yellow-orange
  • Clarity: VS1
  • Polish: Excellent
  • Measurement: 4.15 x 4.11 x 2.85 mm

Looking for a more durable version of the citrine gemstone? The 0.43-Carat Vivid Yellow-Orange Cushion Cut Diamond by Blue Nile is an outstanding orange diamond with eye-catching lemon-like color. This GIA-graded stone has excellent polish with VS1 clarity. Its yellow color makes it a bit lighter, adding to its greater sparkle.

While a natural intense orange diamond may cost you thousands of dollars, this gem has a dramatically reduced price due to its secondary yellow color. It works best for those who don’t want an over-the-top orange hue for their jewelry piece. Its subtle yellow hue gives it a soothing color with no added flashiness.

Most of the orange diamonds sold in the market are often styled in radiant cuts. This shape is a perfect choice if you want to add fire to an orange diamond’s color. It also enhances its brilliance and sparkle, thanks to its numerous facets and a large table. 

ProsCons
Stands out on any jewelry settings
Looks smaller when viewed from above
Excellent brilliance
No sharp edges

#3. 0.46-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Heart Diamond by James Allen – Editor’s Choice

0.46 Carat Heart Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.46 carats
  • Shape: Heart
  • Color: Fancy vivid yellowish-orange
  • Clarity: VS2
  • Polish: Good
  • Measurement: 4.66 x 4.81 mm

Add fire to your romance with this heart-shaped orange diamond from James Allen. The 0.46-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Heart Diamond by James Allen offers a romantic touch to your engagement ring with its properly-cut heart-shaped diamond. This gem has a remarkably stunning deep orange color that offers unmatched brilliance. 

This beautiful orange diamond has a brownish amber color saturation and dynamic luster. It is certainly a great find with its good polish and VS2 clarity, making it a great addition to the best orange diamond cuts. 

Its modern shape offers incredible beauty and femininity for women’s jewelry items. Although it is not a popular option for engagement rings, it offers an excellent alternative for ladies who want something unique and non-conventional. It has an eye-catching appearance when mounted in a solitaire but looks more stunning when set in other elaborate styles. 

ProsCons
Suitable for solitaire and elaborate settings
Inclusions may be easily noticed.
Unique, unconventional shape
Goes out of style easily
Meaningful shape and color
Slightly expensive
Very feminine

#4. 1.20-Carat Deep Brownish Orange Round Diamond by Blue Nile

1.20-Carat Deep Brownish Orange Round Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 1.20 carats
  • Shape: Round
  • Color: Deep brownish orange
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Polish: Very good
  • Measurement: 6.42 x 6.47 x 4.42 mm

If you want to keep it classy and conventional while going over a carat, then this next selection from Blue Nile will certainly astound you. The 1.20-Carat Deep Brownish Orange Round Diamond is just perfect with a very good polish and symmetry at a full 1.20 carats. The colors orange and brown offer an abundant shine and twinkle that you want from a diamond. 

This orange diamond offers an exceptional brown-orange color that offers an amazing sparkle every time you glance. It goes well for those who want a mysterious-looking center stone that doesn’t command too much attention. Due to its exceptional cut, this gem features an incredible amount of fire. 

Round brilliant diamonds have a classic appearance, making them easy to complement in countless styles. These include a vintage engagement ring, modern round-cut diamond rings, a pavé setting, and a three-stone ring. 

ProsCons
Goes well with any finger-type jewelryMost expensive among diamond cuts
Most brilliant among diamond cuts
Very versatile in any ring setting
Unmatchable sparkle

#5. 0.19-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Oval Diamond by James Allen

0.19 Carat Oval Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.19 carats
  • Shape: Oval
  • Color: Fancy vivid yellowish-orange
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Polish: Very good
  • Measurement: 4.2 x 3.41 mm

There aren’t many orange-colored diamonds that showcase the presence of light amber. One great example is the 0.19-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Oval Diamond by James Allen, a GIA-graded diamond with a very good polish and SI2 clarity. This oval-cut fancy vivid yellowish orange weighing 0.19 carats makes a dazzling engagement ring.

This gem offers a subtle orange hue with the right amount of fire and brilliance. Although it is not a highly popular cut for diamonds, this stone exhibits a unique and eye-catching appearance. It combines sophistication and elegance in a single gem, great for anyone who wants a little something out of the ordinary. 

This oval-cut orange diamond offers an unmatched brilliance, thanks to its unique arrangement and a high number of facets. It is a great alternative to expensive round brilliants if you want a sparkling gem minus the conventional look.

ProsCons
Great value for moneyIncludes slightly noticeable inclusions
Lengthens the fingers
Tends to exhibit a bowtie effect
Unique arrangement

#6. 0.50-Carat Deep Yellowish Orange Radiant Cut Diamond by Blue Nile

0.50-Carat Deep Yellowish Orange Radiant Cut Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.50 carats
  • Shape: Radiant
  • Color: Deep yellowish-orange
  • Clarity: SI1
  • Polish: Very good
  • Measurement: 5.29 x 3.71 x 2.67 mm

Is vivid orange still not enough for you? This Blue Nile offering aims to satisfy every orange jewelry fix. The 0.50-Carat Deep Yellowish Orange Radiant Cut Diamond will surely take your breath away. This half-carat orange diamond sparkles radiantly with a deep orange hue whenever the light hits it. 

Impressively brilliant, this orange diamond offers immense brilliance and fire in every facet. This gem is a great choice if you prefer a non-round diamond with amazing sparkle. It has an eye-catching hue that delivers extra presence on any jewelry setting.

With its very good symmetry and polish, this stunning gem makes a fantastic gift for a special lady in your life. You can set it in a white gold channel or solitaire setting.

ProsCons
An eye-catching deep orange hue
Not very popular for jewelry settings
Perfect for vintage settings
Hard-to-beat brilliance
Impressive cut quality

#7. 0.31-Carat Fancy Intense Orange Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen

0.31 Carat Cushion Modified Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.31 carats
  • Shape: Cushion modified
  • Color: Fancy intense yellow-orange
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Polish: Good
  • Measurement: 3.92 x 3.58 mm

Looking for an orange diamond for your vintage engagement ring? The 0.31-Carat Fancy Intense Orange Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen is one of the most beautiful orange diamonds in James Allen’s orange diamond collection. This GIA-certified cushion-cut diamond boasts of its fancy intense yellow-orange hue that is simply gorgeous.

At 0.31 carats, this orange diamond gives off a cotton candy color that is unique and soothing to the eye. It makes a fantastic choice for almost any jewelry setting, especially for fashionistas. Plus, its color doesn’t command too much attention, making it suitable for low-key and sophisticated jewelry pieces.

This radiant-cut orange diamond delivers a decent amount of brilliance and hue for any jewelry item due to its large open table. They are largely popular for halo settings, vintage engagement rings, pavé halo, and channel set. 

ProsCons
Perfect for a personalized engagement ring
Other shapes are better at showcasing their color
Very durable due to its rounded edges
Its large table means inclusions are easier to spot
Reflects colored and white light well
Less expensive than other cuts

#8. 0.83-Carat Intense Yellow-Orange Pear Shaped Diamond by Blue Nile

0.83-Carat Intense Yellow-orange Pear Shaped Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.83 carats
  • Shape: Pear
  • Color: Intense yellow-orange
  • Clarity: VVS2
  • Polish: Excellent
  • Measurement: 7.62 x 4.79 x 3.14 mm

Unlike other orange diamond cuts, this next gem boasts of its unique teardrop cut that looks like an icy snowflake. The 0.83-Carat Intense Yellow-Orange Pear Shaped Diamond by Blue Nile is perfect for almost any kind of ring. It has a lemony-like color that imitates the unique color of a citrine gemstone.

With its pear-shaped cut, this orange diamond is fashioned with one of the best diamond shapes known for bringing out a gem’s strongest color. It combines the best features of marquise and round cut while retaining its unique signature form. Since pear-cut diamonds are known as an old-fashioned cut, you can set this stone in modern jewelry settings with an added vintage touch. 

This orange diamond is perfect for those with short, stubby fingers. Its eye-catching hue and elongated shape help create a slimming impression. You might want to get your hands immediately on this offer since this gem is quite a rare find. 

ProsCons
Perfect for vintage settings and modern styles
Requires extra secured settings
Slightly affordable than other cuts
It may include a bowtie effect
Attention-grabbing orange hue
Tends to show inclusions
Ideal for sophisticated tastes

#9. 0.31-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Pear Diamond by James Allen

0.31 Carat Pear Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.31 carats
  • Shape: Pear
  • Color: Fancy vivid yellowish-orange
  • Clarity: SI1
  • Polish: Excellent
  • Measurement: 6.38 x 3.78 mm

A honey-colored pear-shaped diamond does not come easy. If you are looking for the greatest jewelry finds, you might want to hold on to this gorgeous orange diamond from James Allen. The 0.31-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Pear Diamond by James Allen is a pumpkin-colored gem with an incredible presence for any jewelry design. 

At 0.31 carats, this orange diamond is styled in a soft-sided fancy shape that offers a stunning flair of an orange hue. Despite being an unpopular diamond shape, this gem will certainly put you under the spotlight. A properly cut pear diamond is hard to come by, so this one will certainly exceed your expectation. 

With its blazing orange hue, this gem will give you an unparalleled shine at every angle. It also appears impressive and bigger than a traditional orange diamond with a more visible surface area than those with the same carat weight. Bezel, halo, and prong settings are the best styles to accentuate its unique color and shape.

ProsCons
Appears larger than round brilliants
Potential for damage
Great for hand-type jewelry
Unique style
Lower price

#10. 0.66-Carat Deep Brownish Orange Oval Diamond by Blue Nile

0.54-Carat Deep Brownish Yellowish Orange Oval Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.66 carats
  • Shape: Oval
  • Color: Deep brownish orange
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Polish: Very good
  • Measurement: 5.91 x 4.44 x 3.34 mm

Looking for a deep honey-colored gemstone? Look no more because Blue Nile offers you an extremely stunning yet affordable offer. The 0.66-Carat Deep Brownish Orange Oval Diamond by Blue Nile offers a mesmerizing gem that you cannot avoid gazing at. It has a deep brownish-orange color that is just above half a carat that delivers endless mounting options. 

When mounted on pendants and ring settings, this gem will certainly turn heads. Its unique shape allows the diamond to radiate with both orange and brown tints whenever the light hits it. Due to its oval-cut design, this orange diamond gives you a forgiving style without sacrificing its brilliance and durability. 

For those who plan to build their engagement rings, this orange diamond can be mounted in several styles, including halo settings in yellow or white gold with a pavé band and milgrain solitaire rings in white or rose gold. 

ProsCons
Unique arrangement
Tends to show inclusions or blemishes
Extremely brilliant
Quite affordable

Top Pick for Best Orange Diamonds: 1.18-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Radiant Diamond by James Allen

Also known as fire diamonds, orange diamonds are among the rarest and extraordinary fancy-colored diamonds. Natural orange diamonds have a splashy orange color that resembles a pumpkin. Although orange diamonds are not quite popular in the jewelry world, they are still considered intriguing and eye-catching.

Orange diamonds are a rare variety of diamonds that are highly valued among jewelry lovers and diamond collectors. They come in different features that affect their overall quality and price, including their intensity, saturation, tone, clarity, and cuts.

This buying guide has made it easier for all diamond buyers out there who are keen to own a lovely orange diamond in their collection or for their engagement ring. It has included some of the best cuts and hues from two leading online diamond retailers: Blue Nile and James Allen. While every selection is equally stunning and eye-catching, the 1.18-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Radiant Diamond by James Allen is the top pick for the best orange diamonds. 

This honey-colored diamond makes a stylish piece for any jewelry collection. A GIA-certified diamond, this gorgeous diamond gem has a blazing fire impression that will surely make heads turn. Generally, an orange diamond with a pumpkin color saturation is hard to come by. Thanks to James Allen, they guarantee that they offer some of the best fancy-colored diamonds you will ever find. 

This orange diamond offers a very good polish and good symmetry. It combines a cushion and princess cut with perfectly-cut eight corners. It gives off a stylish and elegant look and a unique, deep cut that maximizes its color refraction with a highly brilliant luster. 

This fiery orange diamond is a great choice for any engagement ring design that will surely give off an incredible fire and sparkle. With its carefully beveled corners, this gem has substantial durability against breakage and chips, perfect for ladies who have an active lifestyle.


Best Brands for Orange Diamonds

Those planning to buy an orange diamond online, always pick a licensed and highly reputable jeweler that offers GIA-certified diamonds. You should also consider if they offer quality images and videos of the actual diamond to allow you to evaluate a diamond more closely before making a purchase. Blue Nile and James Allen offer some quality diamonds with exceptional customer service.

Read about their humble beginnings and how they have become one of the best diamond retailers worldwide. 

Blue Nile

Blue Nile ranks among the market-leading online vendors of certified diamonds. Mark Vadon founded the company in 1999 after discovering that many customers are often confused, intimidated, and overwhelmed by the traditional jewelry-shopping experience. 

From there, Mark acquired an online-based diamond retailer called Internet Diamonds. The website took on a new name called Blue Nile, taken from the premise of introducing a smarter way of selling diamond jewelry. 

The company’s main purpose is to become a premier specialty retailer of diamonds and fine jewelry. Their main strategy focuses on delivering an empowering shopping experience while offering premium diamonds and jewelry items at the best value and price. 

Today, Blue Nile offers the best customer experience by offering abundant selections of engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry. They also offer fancy-colored diamonds, customizable diamond rings, diamond consultations, and finely-crafted jewelry pieces.

James Allen

Before James Allen became one of the most respected online jewelry vendors, four creative minds worked together before reaching their unparalleled success today. They combined 60 years of expertise in the jewelry business to develop the best business strategy.  

In 2006, James Allen started to innovate how consumers shop for diamond jewelry. They took advantage of the e-commerce industry and transformed their website by offering the most convenient and worry-free experience of buying diamond engagement rings. 

Besides selling diamond jewelry, James Allen aims to ingrain knowledge to their customers on how to find the best diamond rings without going to a physical jewelry store. One of their techniques is the Diamond Display Technology, where customers can inspect their diamond selections in 360° imagery with superior magnification. 

Today, James Allen sells over 200,000 ethically-sourced diamonds on their website. They also offer exceptional real-time customer service and hundreds of customizable jewelry styles. 


Features to Consider When Buying Orange Diamonds (Buyer’s Guide)

An orange diamond’s value can be determined based on several quality factors. Read below and learn how to find the best orange diamond fit for your tastes and budget.

Saturation

Saturation refers to a diamond’s color strength, or how much color is visible and how intense it is. The further the spectrum, the more vibrant and richer the saturation. One example, a fancy intense orange diamond has a greater saturation than a fancy orange diamond.

Tone

Tone refers to the light penetration, whether how light or dark an orange diamond appears. This factor affects the perceived intensity of a diamond’s natural color. An untrained eye can easily mistake a fancy orange with a darker tone for a more valuable and expensive fancy intense orange. 

Intensity

An orange diamond’s intensity depends on the combination of tone and saturation, which represents its vibrance and strength. In general, the intensity often affects cost and demand. The more intense the color, the rarer it is. 

Fluorescence

Fluorescence is what causes diamonds to glow when exposed to ultraviolet light. Orange diamonds typically have medium to strong yellow tones, giving the stone a golden luminosity and pastel hue.

Color Distribution

The color distribution is an essential factor in identifying the value of an orange diamond. It refers to how uniform the color spreads across the stone. They are often graded as even or uneven. Uneven color distributions can decrease an orange diamond’s worth and appearance.

Carat

A carat defines a diamond’s weight. Although two diamonds have the same shade and clarity, the heavier diamond is more expensive than the lighter one.

Clarity

Clarity refers to a diamond’s structural perfection. Although flaws or inclusions are not often visible to the naked eye, gemological laboratories use clarity scales to determine a diamond’s internal clarity.

Cut

Cut refers to how a diamond is polished to reveal its natural qualities and bring out its natural color and brilliance. It also helps a diamond appear bigger than its actual carat weight.


Conclusion

Orange diamonds are intriguing, alluring, and highly valued gemstones among diamond enthusiasts and jewelry collectors. They are called fire or pumpkin diamonds due to their eye-catching orange hue. These include natural orange diamonds, known as the rarest and extraordinary diamond variety. 

Like any fancy-colored diamond variety, buying the best orange diamond requires deep knowledge and familiarity. Any two orange diamond varieties with similar GIA certification can still differ significantly in value and price. Learning to evaluate them involves plenty of factors, including beauty, saturation, hue, color rarity, cutting style, etc. 

The 1.18-Carat Fancy Vivid Orange Radiant Diamond by James Allen is the top pick for the best orange diamonds. This honey-colored diamond has an eye-catching look with incredible fire and brilliance.  

This orange diamond offers a very good polish and good symmetry. It combines a cushion and princess cut with perfectly-cut eight corners. It gives off a stylish and elegant look and a unique, deep cut that maximizes its color refraction with a highly brilliant luster.

Hopefully, you have found this article helpful once you are ready to shop for the best orange diamond. You may want to share the knowledge with your friends by sharing it on your social networks.


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

How does the secondary color affect an orange diamond’s price and value?

The three modifying secondary hues in orange diamonds include yellow-orange, pink-orange, and brown-orange. Unfortunately, finding a natural orange diamond with no secondary hue is almost unlikely. A pure orange diamond with no modified color is considered valuable than the ones with a secondary hue. 

Brown is the most common secondary hue with a lesser price than a yellow-orange variety. You may consider yourself lucky if you find a vivid orange or pure, intense orange diamond without any secondary hue. They are exceptionally valued and truly one-of-a-kind. 

How do orange diamonds obtain their color?

Like yellow diamonds, orange diamonds acquire their color due to the nitrogen element’s presence. However, although these two diamonds obtain their signature color from the same element, they still produce a different color due to their differences during formation.

Due to the nitrogen atom’s covalent bonding, a diamond obtains its rare and extraordinary color. This particular arrangement among orange diamonds is called hyper-specific. It leads to the absorption of yellow and blue light, where it splashes out an orange hue in diamonds. 

How do natural orange diamonds differ from treated orange diamonds?

The high price and exceptional rarity of these stunning gems led to a massive and continuous demand for natural orange diamonds, which the jewelry market cannot satisfy. As a result, jewelry makers created a niche for treated orange diamonds, a great budget alternative for those who cannot afford natural orange diamonds. 

Treated diamonds are created under specified laboratory conditions that aim to imitate how natural diamonds are formed. Thus, treated diamonds are known as cheaper, artificial solutions to the orange diamond demand. 

Treated orange diamonds are originally colorless diamonds sent to a gemological lab to undergo a chemical treatment process called HPHT (High-Pressure High Temperature). The process involves putting incredible pressure on a diamond’s shell to transform its color to orange while retaining its white-colored interior. 

However, for those who insist on getting a genuine and natural orange diamond, you must ensure that it comes with an authentic certification issued by a reputable gemological institute, such as GIA or AGS.  

Related Resources:

Learn More in Our Related Articles

Shop Online to Save

james allen
james allen reviews

OUR #1 RATED ONLINE JEWELRY STORE

james allen
james allen reviews

Shop Online to Save

james allen
james allen reviews