Top 10 Best Gemstone Rings | 2021 Reviews (Blue Nile)

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.

Since ancient times, gemstones have been used as adornments or astrological tools. Nowadays, wearing one can be an exciting and overwhelming experience, given their ethereal nature, combined with all the rainbow colors and extraordinary beauty. Gemstones can be used as stunning accents for any jewelry item, from earrings, necklaces, bracelets, and rings.

Choosing a gemstone ring often depends on its durability and aesthetic value. It is also crucial to be assured of the gemstone’s authenticity and quality to avoid unpleasant surprises. However, since gemstones are largely expensive, you find plenty of fake gems sold everywhere disguised as real, precious stones. 

While the Internet offers multiple options for buying gemstone jewelry, not all information is reliable or informative. Whether you are buying a gemstone ring for meditation purposes or as a fashion statement, you came to the right source. This buying guide will help you find the right gemstone ring that suits your preference and budget. 

Learn all about the latest gemstone rings in different styles, colors, and grades. This guide will break down all the essentials about quality, durability, and pricing so that you can make a confident and informed choice. Whether you are looking for a diamond, ruby, sapphire, emerald, you will discover all the best recommendations and in-depth information in this article. 

Top 10 Best Gemstone Rings Reviewed

  1. Morganite and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring by Blue Nile – Best Overall
  2. Double Row Pave Multicolor Ring by James Allen – Best Value
  3. Aquamarine and Diamond Infinity Twist Ring by Blue Nile – Editor’s Choice
  4. Dainty Peridot Bezel Diamond Ring (Brevani) by James Allen
  5. Cushion London Blue Topaz and Aquamarine Trillion Ring by Blue Nile
  6. Bypass Duo Garnet and Diamond Ring (Brevani) by James Allen
  7. Oval Blue Sapphire and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile
  8. Open Opal and Diamond Ring by James Allen
  9. Three-Stone Emerald and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile
  10. Wavy Ruby and Diamond Ring by James Allen

#1. Morganite and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring by Blue Nile – Best Overall

Morganite and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring in 14k Rose Gold (8x8mm)

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (1) morganite, (24) diamonds
  • Metal: 14k rose gold
  • Average carat weight: (0.17ct.) diamonds
  • Ring Dimensions: 1.5 – 2.0 mm
  • Shape: (cushion) morganite, (round) diamond
  • Setting: (prong) morganite, (pavé) diamond

Fancy a peach-colored gemstone for your jewelry ensemble? Exquisite in every sense, the Morganite and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring by Blue Nile completely embodies beauty and sophistication. This stunning morganite gemstone ring exhibits a halo of encircling pavé-set diamond set in a lush pink 14k rose gold. 

Despite its subtle pink shade, this ring occupies a huge presence on your finger, giving it an eye-catching appearance. The halo of diamonds emphasizes the morganite center stone, drawing attention while making it appear more brilliant and larger. Plus, it goes well with pastel-colored outfits.

You may also check out the Aquamarine and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring, which sports the same setting and style. The original price for this piece is $1,400, but you can get it at a much cheaper price if you encounter Blue Nile’s special offers. 

ProsCons
Diamond accents add texture to morganite.
Takes too much presence on the finger
Beautifully modernToo big for some
Eye-catching piece
Plenty of bling

#2. Double Row Pave Multicolor Ring by James Allen – Best Value

Double Row Pave Multicolor Ring by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (3) diamond, (6) ruby, (6) emerald, (6) yellow sapphire, (6) pink sapphire, (8) blue sapphire
  • Metal: 14k yellow gold
  • Average carat weight: (0.04ct) diamond, (0.12ct.) ruby, (0.12ct.) emerald, (0.12ct.) yellow sapphire, (0.12ct.) pink sapphire, (0.15) blue sapphire
  • Ring Dimensions: 2.9 mm
  • Shape: Round
  • Setting: pavé 

When buying gemstone rings, the more colorful it is, the better. The Double Row Pave Multicolor Ring by James Allen features all your favorite gemstones in one gorgeous ring. It showcases two rows of pavé-set multicolored gemstones set in a sleek 14k yellow gold band. From diamonds, rubies, green emeralds, pink sapphire, yellow sapphire, to blue sapphire, this natural gemstone ring will surely satisfy your fancy for everything colorful. 

This ring matches almost every outfit you have in your wardrobe. It’s candy colors certainly shines and illuminates when light passes through it. Despite its multicolored setting, this ring won’t demand too much presence when worn. 

This real gemstone ring costs $800 at James Allen. If you want to stick with a dual-color gemstone ring, you may consider the White Gold Double Row Pave Sapphire and Diamond Ring designed in the same style. 

ProsCons
Multicolor ring
Stones are at risk of falling off
Very colorfulStones are too tiny

#3. Aquamarine and Diamond Infinity Twist Ring by Blue Nile – Editor’s Choice

Aquamarine and Diamond Infinity Twist Ring in 14k White Gold (7x7mm)

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (1) aquamarine, (34) diamond
  • Metal: 14k white gold
  • Average carat weight: 0.09 – 0.12ct. (diamond)
  • Ring Dimensions: 2.0 – 3.3 mm
  • Shape: (cushion) aquamarine, (round) diamond
  • Setting: (prong) aquamarine, (pavé) diamond

Is vivid dark blue sapphire too much for you? How about a light blue aquamarine gemstone? The Aquamarine and Diamond Infinity Twist Ring feature a cushion-cut aquamarine stone adorned with pavé-set round brilliant-cut diamonds in an infinity twist design of 14k white gold. 

This ring makes a perfect engagement ring for women born in March with an aquamarine gemstone. It exhibits a unique infinity design, with a split and joined shank that signifies everlasting love, devotion, and unity. The setting includes 34 pavé-set diamonds, with an average carat weight of 0.12ct. 

If a diamond center stone is too expensive for your budget, this gemstone engagement ring will only cost you $840. For those who prefer pastel pink, you may consider the Morganite and Diamond Infinity Twist Ring. 

ProsCons
Setting complements the center stone
The band is thinner than expected
Stunning pale blue aquamarineA little smaller than the photo
Excellent quality and sparkle
Looks great on its own
ALSO READ:  Top 7 Best Thumb Rings l 2021 Reviews + Guide

#4. Dainty Peridot Bezel Diamond Ring (Brevani) by James Allen

Dainty Peridot Bezel Diamond Ring (Brevani) by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (1) peridot, (4) diamond
  • Metal: 14k yellow gold
  • Carats: (0.20ct.) peridot, (0.06ct.) diamond
  • Ring Dimensions: 7 x 7 mm
  • Shape: (princess) peridot, (round) diamond
  • Setting: bezel-set

A stackable gemstone ring makes a budget-friendly fashion jewelry piece. The Dainty Peridot Bezel Diamond Ring is a thin, dainty ring designed by Brevani. It features bezel-set peridot as its center stone and four pieces of diamonds as side stones. The ring is embellished with fine milgrain details for added elegance. 

This ring goes well for women with delicate tastes in jewelry. It doesn’t appear flashy and sits well on your index finger. You can pair it up with other gemstone rings to make it more stunning and noticeable. 

This ring costs $500 at James Allen, including quality packaging, free FedEx shipping, and a lifetime warranty. 

ProsCons
Well-secured bezel setting
Diamond accents are too small
Great stackable ring
Not ideal for large fingers
Vivid green peridotNot too sparkly

#5. Cushion London Blue Topaz and Aquamarine Trillion Ring by Blue Nile

Cushion London Blue Topaz and Aquamarine Trillion Ring in 14k White Gold

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (1) London blue topaz, (2) aquamarine
  • Metal: 14k white gold
  • Ring Dimensions: 1.4 x 1.9 mm
  • Shape: (cushion) London blue topaz, (side trillion) aquamarine
  • Enhancement: (irradiation) London blue topaz, (heating) side trillion aquamarine
  • Setting: prong setting

Be the brightest among the stars with this dazzling gemstone ring from Blue Nile. The Cushion London Blue Topaz and Aquamarine Trillion Ring feature two trillion-cut light blue aquamarines encircling a center cushion-cut London blue topaz set in white gold for an eye-catching appeal. 

This ring blends the contrasting blue shades of light blue aquamarine and London blue topaz to resemble the sea’s untamed beauty. It perfectly matches a dainty blue gown or any formal-looking outfit. 

You can get this ring for only $834, which you can find in other gemstone varieties, such as amethyst, aquamarine, and Rose de France amethyst. 

ProsCons
Aquamarine perfectly highlights the blue topaz
Very large center stone
Available in three other gemstones
Very eye-catching

#6. Bypass Duo Garnet and Diamond Ring (Brevani) by James Allen

Bypass Duo Garnet and Diamond Ring (Brevani) by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (2) garnet, (10) diamond
  • Metal: 14k rose gold
  • Average carat weight: (4.02ct.) garnet, (0.08ct.) diamond
  • Ring Dimensions: 1.5 mm
  • Shape: (baguette) garnet, (round) diamond
  • Setting: (bypass) baguette, (pavé) diamond

Besides solitaire and halo rings, gemstone rings can be styled in various designs and settings, made especially for avant-garde tastes. The Bypass Duo Garnet and Diamond Ring by James Allen features two baguette garnets embellished with pavé-set diamonds in a 14k rose gold band. This ring is certainly a standout in any jewelry collection.

This unique gemstone ring foregoes the typical design used for fashion statement rings. Bypass design is not very common when it comes to gemstone rings.  James Allen blends its unique setting and the vivid red color of garnet to form a very eye-catching gemstone ring. Its unique design will certainly make you stand out on any occasion. You can get this ring for $870 at James Allen, including an elegant jewelry packaging. 

ProsCons
Stunning vivid red garnet
Very tiny diamond accents
Very noticeableCatches on clothing
Unique setting
Leaves red marks

#7. Oval Blue Sapphire and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile

Oval Sapphire and Diamond Ring in Platinum (10x8mm)

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (1) blue sapphire, (48) diamond
  • Metal: 14k white gold
  • Average carat weight: (0.24ct.) diamond
  • Ring Dimensions: 1.7 x 1.8 mm
  • Shape: (oval) sapphire, (round) diamond
  • Setting: (prong) blue sapphire, (pavé) diamond

A chain design is not only used for necklaces and bracelets, but they also make a stunning design for gemstone rings. The Oval Blue Sapphire and Diamond Ring feature connected chain links of pavé-set diamonds that meet at the middle to highlight the deep blue oval sapphire at the center. 

This ring has a very defined statement that will not overwhelm you. The blue sapphire’s medium-light blue shade gives off a stunning dash of color that gives life to the entire setting. Due to its refined style, you can wear this ring as a standalone jewelry piece.

Blue Nile offers this ring for $1,590. It is also available in emerald for $1,600.

ProsCons
Very dainty in designA little pricey

#8. Open Opal and Diamond Ring by James Allen

Open Opal and Diamond Ring by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (4) opal, (7) diamond
  • Metal: 14k rose gold
  • Carats: (0.46ct.) opal, (0.10ct.) diamond
  • Ring Dimensions: 2 mm
  • Shape: (marquise) opal, (round) diamond
  • Setting: prong

James Allen is known for selling unique pieces that will sweep you off your feet. A great example is the Open Opal and Diamond Ring from James Allen. Elegant and timeless, this opal and diamond cluster ring features four marquise-shaped opals embellished with round shaped diamonds in a sleek 14k rose gold band. 

This warm and gorgeous ring from James Allen is a perfect non-conventional open ring for women who have unique tastes for jewelry. It has a one-of-a-kind statement with its asymmetrical stones that looks feminine, enchanting, and elegant. Women who love floral accents for their jewelry will surely fall in love with this piece.

This ring is currently offered on James Allen’s website for only $850. 

ProsCons
Unique, unconventional gemstone ringRequires careful handling
Sophisticated and feminine looking

#9. Three-Stone Emerald and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile

Three-Stone Emerald and Diamond Ring in 14k Yellow Gold

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (3) emerald, (1) diamond
  • Metal: 14k yellow gold
  • Average carat weight: (0.30ct.) diamond 
  • Ring Dimensions: 2.5 mm
  • Enhancement: oiling/resin
  • Setting: (prong) emerald, (pavé) diamond

Vintage pieces make a classic and timeless statement to any outfit. If vintage rings are your favorite, you have to check out this elegant piece from Blue Nile. The Three-Stone Emerald and Diamond Ring feature a trio of lush green emeralds set in a 14k yellow gold band with milgrain trim details, framing tiny round diamonds. Its diamond accents reflect their white light to highlight the beauty of its emerald gemstone. 

This vintage gemstone ring has a refined and elegant statement that is perfect for black-tie occasions to unleash your inner charm. It is also an ideal present for weddings, anniversaries, and birthdays. 

Besides emerald, Blue Nile offers this ring in ruby and sapphire. You can get this for $2,380, but you can also wait for special offers for a discounted price. 

ProsCons
Available in ruby and blue sapphire
The prong setting is too delicate
Very intricate in design
ALSO READ:  Top 7 Best Yellow Sapphire Rings | 2021 Reviews + Guide

#10. Wavy Ruby and Diamond Ring by James Allen

Wavy Ruby and Diamond Ring by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Gemstone: (10) ruby, (128) diamond
  • Metal: 14k rose gold
  • Average carat weight: (0.64ct.) ruby, (0.49ct.) diamond
  • Ring Dimensions: 2.4 mm
  • Shape: (round) ruby, (round) diamond
  • Setting: pavé-set

Are you looking for a gemstone ring that looks elegant and eye-catching? Then you will certainly love James Allen’s Wavy Ruby and Diamond Ring. This striking statement ring features deep red rubies embellished with defining waves of pavé-set diamonds in a 14k rose gold band. With its heavily-accented gemstones, this ring makes a perfect family heirloom.

This ruby gemstone ring is one of the most eye-catching pieces on this list. It occupies a large presence on your finger that will dazzle anyone who lays their eyes on it. You can use this ring as a fashionable statement piece to add flair to your outfit with its vivid red color. However, you need to take good care of this ring due to its very delicate design. 

This ring can be yours for $2,210 only at James Allen’s fine jewelry collection.  

ProsCons
Striking red ruby accentSlightly expensive
Reasonably priced

Top Pick for Best Gemstone Rings: Morganite and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring by Blue Nile

Colorful gemstone rings are a not-so-new trend in jewelry made specifically for people who want an extra pop of color and personality to traditional colorless diamond rings. Some fashionistas go for the color-me look with blue, yellow, or pink diamonds, while others turn to gemstones to find their other varieties of color.

While every gemstone ring mentioned in this guide is unique on its own, there will always be a bestseller that easily captures the hearts of jewelry lovers. After thoughtful and careful consideration of the stunning selections in this list, the Morganite and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring by Blue Nile is the top pick for the best gemstone ring.

Even at first glance, this ring certainly evokes elegance and sophistication. It features a peach-colored morganite on its center, surrounded by pavé-set diamonds in a lush pink 14k rose gold band. Exquisite in every sense, this stunning ring has a very feminine appearance that will certainly complete any jewelry collection. 

This effortlessly charming gemstone ring gives off a greater presence yet classic appearance on your finger. The halo of diamonds emphasizes the subtle pink shade of the morganite center stone, drawing more attention while making it brilliant and larger. This particular ring is a great option if you’re looking for something feminine, elegant, and delicate. It goes well with dainty outfits or pastel-colored gowns.

If you’re a huge fan of pastel blue, you may also like the Aquamarine and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring, which sports the same setting and style. The original price for this piece is $1,400, but you can get it at a much cheaper price if you encounter any of their special offers.

Applying colored gemstones in fancy rings offers multiple options to showcase individual personality and style. Jewelers continue to introduce new trends by adding new twists and designs while helping you achieve a timeless and contemporary look.


Best Brands for Gemstone Rings

Before making a purchase, it is highly recommended to do an intensive search for the most reliable and reputable jeweler. This way, you can get the best price and value for your gemstone ring and have some peace of mind. Knowing the right jeweler involves some key factors, including gemstone certifications from a reputable institution and if they offer a hassle-free return and warranty policy.

This guide has done the entire job for you by providing everything you need to know about gemstone rings, including the best online jewelers. James Allen and Blue Nile are the leading vendors in the online jewelry business. They offer outstanding value for quality, money, and customer service.

Blue Nile

Blue Nile is the leading online retailer of certified gemstone and fine jewelry. It started in 1999 after Mark Vadon, Blue Nile’s founder and executive chairman, recognized that several customers are overwhelmed, confused, and discouraged when shopping for jewelry in local jewelry stores.

From this idea, Mark discovered how the Internet could innovate the traditional jewelry shopping experience. He acquired an online-based diamond vendor, Internet Diamonds, renamed it Blue Nile, and established a new online brand of diamonds and fine jewelry. His main focus is to introduce a smart way of shopping for engagement rings. 

It was only a few years when Mark Vadon’s business plans came to life for his jewelry brand.  Blue Nile became one of the premier specialty retailers of diamond jewelry. They are known for providing an empowering shopping experience while providing high-quality jewelry items at the best value and price. 

Today, Blue Nile offers a top-notch customer experience by providing its customers with a massive online inventory of engagement rings, wedding bands, and fine jewelry. They also offer diamond consultations, finely-crafted jewelry, customizable diamond engagement rings, and fancy-colored diamonds. 

James Allen

Four creative minds were responsible for James Allen’s unparalleled success today. But before the brand became the largest and reputable online jewelry retailer worldwide, the company went through a series of humble beginnings. 

James Allen’s founders combined 60 years of expertise in the jewelry business. Some of them used to work for luxury diamond retailers like Tiffany & Co. With this knowledge, its founders looked for ways to help shoppers search for diamond jewelry without visiting local jewelry stores. They took advantage of the booming e-commerce industry by transforming their former website, dirtcheapdiamonds.com.

James Allen adopted a sophisticated image for its branding and offered the most convenient, stress-free way of buying engagement rings. Besides selling jewelry, James Allen aim to educate customers on finding the perfect jewelry at the best value and price. 

The company is one of the first jewelry retailers to use the Diamond Display Technology, where more than 200,000 diamonds are showcased in a highly magnified 360° imagery. This way, customers can make better decisions before they make a jewelry purchase.  


Features to Consider When Buying Gemstone Rings (Buyer’s Guide)

Learn more about gemstone quality, grades, colors, and types. This section will break down all the essentials about quality, pricing, and durability, so you make a confident and informed decision. 

Budget

The best way to set a budget for a gemstone ring is to be subjective. The age-old rule of saving two to three months’ salary is very outdated. Ideally, spend what you think is comfortable for you and your partner. The right jeweler will offer creative ways to maximize your budget. For those buying a non-diamond gemstone ring, the budget will go towards the carat weight, type of gemstone, and ring style. Gemstone rings often start at $350 and range upwards to $4,000.

Gemstone

Center stones come in different styles and offer unique ways to draw attention, making it the main reason behind its expensive price tag. From diamonds, sapphires, rubies, and emerald, jewelers offer plenty of options depending on your taste. It is recommended to learn about their hidden meanings or choose according to your birthstone. 

Shape

Popular ring shapes include round, cushion, emerald, oval, pear, marquise, princess, etc. Each style has a unique way of highlighting a gemstone’s brilliance, clarity, and color. More often, round and emerald shapes are highly popular picks. 

Metal

Choosing a precious metal depends on the impression you want the ring to invoke. Many prefer the traditional and vintage look of yellow gold, white gold’s versatility, and rose gold’s romantic and feminine feel. Those who want their colorless gemstone with no yellow tinge may opt for platinum. It is a durable choice than gold and has hypoallergenic properties. 

Carat

The carat weight is not only considered when buying diamond engagement rings. It also delivers the largest impact on a gemstone ring’s overall appearance. However, when talking about the price tag, the carat weight for loose gemstones does not significantly increase as you go higher in carat weight. Center stones can go as small as 0.5 carats. 


Conclusion

Gemstone rings are indeed one of the hottest trends in the jewelry industry. They are unusual, beautiful, and of great value. They add a pop of color and personality to any traditional colorless diamond jewelry. From pink, blue, or yellow, the world of gemstones will surely add a splash of color to any jewelry collection.

Buying a gemstone ring is a fun and worthwhile experience given its mystical nature combined with its diverse colors and one-of-a-kind beauty. The Internet offers various selections for buying gemstones, including different styles, settings, colors, precious metals, etc. 

This buying guide has chosen Morganite and Diamond Halo Cushion Ring by Blue Nile as the top pick for the best gemstone ring. It features a peach-colored morganite on its center, surrounded by pavé-set diamonds set in a lush pink 14k rose gold. Equally elegant and sophisticated, this ring is one of the bestsellers in Blue Nile’s gemstone ring category. 

It delivers a profound feminine impression, a perfect addition to a jewelry collection. This effortlessly gorgeous gemstone ring has a noticeable presence yet very subtle and classy at the same time. Its dazzling halo of diamonds highlights the morganite center stone, commanding attention to its lush pink shade. This ring is the perfect piece if you’re looking for something feminine, elegant, and delicate. It goes well with dainty outfits or pastel-colored gowns.

Buying a gemstone ring is a personal decision. While designs go in and out of style, the essential factor when buying any gemstone jewelry is that it should match your style, tastes, and budget. All the gemstone rings featured in this buying guide came from reputable jewelry retailers. You can guarantee its authenticity and quality, giving more value to your money.


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

What should I be cautious about when buying gemstone rings?

Gemstones not only serve as a fashionable jewelry item, but they are also worn for their healing properties and astrological value. When buying gemstones, it is crucial to be assured of their authenticity and quality to avoid unpleasant surprises. Several fraudulent jewelers use different methods to sell fake gems as authentic. As a jewelry buyer, you should be aware of fraud jewelers’ usual tricks to sell fake gemstones to their customers.

It is advisable to buy a gemstone jewelry from a reputable retailer who is always ready to answer your jewelry-related queries with extreme honesty. Investing in a genuine, hallmarked jewelry piece and lab-certified gemstone is the best way to ensure the best value for your money. When purchasing an expensive and rare gemstone from a well-known source, you should be extra careful and must rely on certificates from prestigious gem laboratories like GIA and AGS. 

Why should I buy colored gemstone rings?

Color is often the main reason why people buy a gemstone ring. Colored gems come in different rainbow colors, from deep red ruby, vivid blue sapphire, lush green tsavorite garnet, and kaleidoscopic spinel. Essentially, there’s a particular gem for every color imaginable. 

Another reason is that colored gemstones add more depth and meaning to any jewelry. You can incorporate your birthstone, your partner’s birthstone, and embellish it with diamonds. They also come with historic symbolism, where you could pick one that will inspire you or match your personality. One example is sapphire, associated with truth, sincerity, and faithfulness.  

What is the key factor to consider when picking a colored gemstone?

Durability is the first consideration when picking a gemstone for jewelry. The gem should withstand extreme conditions, like bumps and bangs of everyday wear, household chemicals, humidity, heat, and light exposure. Since gemstones are formed differently and contain various properties, each of them has a specific reaction or tolerance to stressors.

The Mohs scale ranks gem hardness from a scale of 1 (least hard) to 10 (hardest). Gemstones with high durability grade can resist abrasions and scratches, making them ideal choices for rings that will encounter a lifetime of frequent wear. 

Related Resources:

ALSO READ:  Pave Diamond Rings Setting: What to Know Before You Buy

Shop Online to Save

james allen

Best for Online Shopping

james allen reviews
blue nile logo

Best Selections

blue nile reviews
james allen

Our #1 Recommended Jewelry Store

james allen reviews