Top 10 Best Brown Diamonds | 2021 Reviews + Guide

Best Brown Diamonds

Diamonds have always been a huge craze, especially among women, due to their unparalleled brilliance and beauty. However, not everyone can get their hands on this precious gem due to its expensive nature. Well, except for celebrities and the elite. You can see them on TVs and print ads sporting colorless diamonds to fancy-colored ones. 

Clear or colorless diamonds are the sole variety of diamonds that everyone seems familiar with. While well-known fancy-colored diamonds include yellow, blue, and pink, there is also the least popular diamond. They are called chocolate diamonds or brown diamonds. Due to their rarity, they are considered next-level expensive. 

One of the most popular brown diamond items is the chocolate brown diamond earrings worth $16,000, worn by American celebrity and singer Jennifer Lopez. According to diamond experts, brown diamonds are rarer and more stunning than the typical colorless ones. The desirability and image of brown diamonds make them great investments in the jewelry market. 

This diamond buying guide will delve into the best brown diamonds from two of the top online diamond jewelry retailers, James Allen and Blue Nile. It will include different variants of brown diamonds in different shades, cuts, and other special qualities. It will also showcase popular brown diamond jewelry pieces worn by many celebrities over the years.

Read on and find out the best brown diamonds that will make you feel like a dazzling celebrity. 

Top 10 Best Brown Diamonds Reviewed

  1. 0.65-Carat Fancy Yellow Brown Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen – Best Overall
  2. 1.16-Carat Yellowish Brown Radiant Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Best Value
  3. 0.60-Carat Fancy Orange Brown Oval Diamond by James Allen – Editor’s Choice
  4. 0.39-Carat Faint Pinkish Brown Round Diamond by Blue Nile
  5. 0.39-Carat Fancy Brown Heart Diamond by James Allen
  6. 0.46-Carat Brown Pear Shaped Diamond by Blue Nile
  7. 1.02-Carat Fancy Orange Brown Radiant Diamond by James Allen
  8. 0.29-Carat Light Brown Oval Diamond by Blue Nile
  9. 0.70-Carat Fancy Yellowish Brown Round Diamond by James Allen
  10. 0.28-Carat Brown Cushion Cut Diamond by Blue Nile

#1. 0.65-Carat Fancy Yellow Brown Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen – Best Overall

0.65 Carat Cushion Modified Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.65 carats
  • Shape: Cushion modified
  • Color: Fancy yellow-brown
  • Clarity: SI1
  • Polish: Very good
  • Measurement: 5.14 x 5.1 mm

Looking for the perfect center stone to complete your brown diamond ring? Then, this first selection will certainly floor you. The 0.65-Carat Fancy Yellow Brown Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen is simply breathtaking. It is a GIA-certified diamond that offers magnificent brilliance and a rich chocolate hue. 

It is quite rare to find a brown diamond that has a similar color intensity to this one. It is because the properly cut facets of this cushion-cut diamond help enhance its color. Plus, the beauty and brilliance of this brown diamond lie in its vintage look. It is a combination between two popular-cuts – princess and the round, giving it a unique, eye-catching look.

Using this stone, you can customize an equally stunning diamond necklace just like American singer Rihanna. In the 2018 Grammy’s, she was spotted wearing a chocolate diamond-encrusted necklace at a whopping $130,000. 

ProsCons
Perfect for a vintage jewelry pieceThe cushion cut is not great at retaining colors
Doesn’t snag on clothes
Very expensive
No sharp edges

#2. 1.16-Carat Yellowish Brown Radiant Cut Diamond by Blue Nile – Best Value

1.12-Carat Deep Brownish Greenish Yellow Radiant Cut Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 1.16 carats
  • Shape: Radiant
  • Color: Yellowish-brown
  • Clarity: VS2
  • Polish: Good 
  • Measurement: 5.99 x 5.55 x 3.80 mm 

A unique diamond engagement ring deserves an equally unique diamond center stone. One great example is the 1.16-Carat Yellowish Brown Radiant Cut Diamond by Blue Nile. This fancy yellowish brown diamond is a cross between sought-after features: the increasingly fashionable cushion cut and a rich chocolate hue. 

Its 1.16-carat weight and medium fluorescence round out the standout traits of this remarkable gem. However, it’s unmatched brilliance highlights all of its best qualities. It is also fashioned in a radiant-cut shape, one of the most stylish and elegant designs among diamond shapes. This relatively new cut is one of the most popular for fancy-colored diamonds as it maximizes a diamond’s color refraction and brilliance.

This gem may look somewhat similar to what actor Dax Shepard bought for his longtime girlfriend and Hollywood actress Kristen Bell, a champagne diamond engagement ring. Blue Nile offers champagne diamonds in different shapes and sizes to help you create a celebrity-like brown diamond ring.

ProsCons
Forgiving at hiding color tints and inclusionsExtremely expensive
Less likelihood of breakage
May look smaller
Excellent color refraction
No pointed edges

#3. 0.60-Carat Fancy Orange Brown Oval Diamond by James Allen – Editor’s Choice

0.60 Carat Oval Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.60 carats
  • Shape: Oval
  • Color: Fancy orange-brown
  • Clarity: VS2
  • Polish: Excellent
  • Measurement: 5.69 x 4.39 mm

Dazzle like singer-rapper Lizzo, who rocked a chocolate brown diamond jewelry ensemble in the BRIT Awards. While wearing a Hershey chocolate bar wrap dress, she completed her look with an assortment of brown diamond stackable rings and gold hoop earrings, which is a total of 38 carats of brown diamonds. 

You can copy the same look as Lizzo by finding the perfect brown diamond to complement your style. You may want to consider the 0.60-Carat Fancy Orange Brown Oval Diamond by James Allen, a fancy brown diamond with an orange hue. This GIA certified diamond has a VS2 clarity weighing at 0.60 carats. It offers a great combination of the desirable attributes you are looking for in a precious stone. 

An oval-cut brown diamond may be the least popular choice, but it certainly makes a unique and eye-catching jewelry piece. It has an elegant and sophisticated design, great for ladies and avant-garde fashionistas looking for something extraordinary.  

ProsCons
A non-traditional version of the round brilliant
Most oval diamonds have a slight bowtie effect
Provides a slimming look on fingersTends to reveal flaws and inclusions
Perfect for short, stubby fingers
Extreme brilliance

#4. 0.39-Carat Faint Pinkish Brown Round Diamond by Blue Nile

0.39-Carat Faint Pinkish Brown Round Diamond

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.39 carats
  • Shape: Round
  • Color: Faint pinkish brown
  • Clarity: VS2
  • Polish: Very good
  • Measurement: 4.60 x 4.63 x 2.92 mm

If you don’t want a pure dark chocolate diamond for your jewelry but want to settle for a two-colored brown diamond, then this one is a perfect choice. The 0.39-Carat Faint Pinkish Brown Round Diamond by Blue Nile is a gorgeous brown diamond certified by the GIA as a faint pinkish brown diamond at 0.39 carats. 

This brown diamond has a notable secondary hue of pink, giving you an eye-catching pinkish brown diamond at an extremely affordable price tag.  It offers exceptional brilliance and colored reflection, giving the diamond unmatched character and beauty at every angle. It is also fashioned in a round brilliant-cut that showcases an incredible fire and color.

If you fancy a brown-colored diamond engagement ring, you may be inspired by what Alison Brie received from Dave Franco. It is a vintage-inspired two- to a three-carat engagement ring with a center diamond encircled by a double halo of tiny diamonds set in rose gold. 

ProsCons
Most brilliant among diamond shapes
Slightly expensive
Goes well with any finger types
Very common cut
Incredible sparkle

#5. 0.39-Carat Fancy Brown Heart Diamond by James Allen

0.39-Carat Fancy Brown Heart Diamond by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.39 carats
  • Shape: Heart
  • Color: Fancy brown
  • Clarity: SI1
  • Polish: Good
  • Measurement: 4.69 x 4.72 mm

Unleash your inner sweetness and romantic side with this James Allen brown diamond. The 0.39-Carat Fancy Brown Heart Diamond is a unique and instantly recognizable gem for any jewelry piece. This well-cut heart-shaped diamond shows the advantages of what being unique and feminine feels like. 

Lady Gaga’s former fiancée Taylor Kinney gave her a striking six-carat heart-shaped colorless diamond with an estimated price of $500,000. You can get a similar style like this engagement ring at an affordable price by looking for a lower-carat diamond. You may also consider adding a twist to it by opting for a brown diamond.

This gem makes an excellent center stone for an engagement ring as a heart-shaped diamond signifies a timeless symbol of love. It is also an impressive alternative to the more common diamond shapes. Due to its subtle brown shade, you can use this in various feminine jewelry pieces, such as pendants, bracelets, and earrings. 

ProsCons
Unique and unconventional style
Can be in danger of going out of style
Meaningful shape and colorInclusions tend to be easily seen
Certainly eye-catching
Very modern shape

#6. 0.46-Carat Brown Pear Shaped Diamond by Blue Nile

0.46-Carat Brown Pear Shaped Diamond by Blue Nile

Specifications: 

  • Carat Weight: 0.46 carats 
  • Shape: Pear
  • Color: Brown
  • Clarity: SI1
  • Polish: Good
  • Measurement: 6.09 x 4.20 x 2.46 mm 

Round brilliant diamonds for engagement rings are a thing of the past. Now is the time to consider other unique and modern shapes, like this pear-shaped diamond from Blue Nile. The 0.46-Carat Brown Pear Shaped Diamond is a stunning fancy brown diamond with remarkable color saturation and luster. 

This teardrop-shaped gem is a versatile diamond loose stone that looks perfect in vintage settings and sleek, modern designs. It is a combination of marquise and round brilliant cut, topped with its unique signature shape. Pear shapes are known as one of the best diamond shapes that reveal a diamond’s strongest color. 

British personality Victoria Beckham has an enviable collection of engagement rings given by her husband David Beckham, for each year of their 20-year marriage. As a fashion icon, Victoria always wants something unique and bigger for her bling and baubles. It includes her enormous pear-shaped solitaire ring with an estimated 15 to 17 carats, set in a vintage-style platinum band. 

ProsCons
Suitable for any settings
Watch out for the bowtie effect.
Perfect for short fingersQuite vulnerable to breakage
Very eye-catching

#7. 1.02-Carat Fancy Orange Brown Radiant Diamond by James Allen

1.02-Carat Fancy Orange Brown Radiant Diamond by James Allen

Specifications:

  • Carat Weight: 1.02 carats
  • Shape: Radiant
  • Color: Fancy orange-brown
  • Clarity: I1
  • Polish: Excellent
  • Measurement: 6.34 x 4.56 mm

Introducing a stunning brown diamond with a remarkable slight orange tone, the 1.02-Carat Fancy Orange Brown Radiant Diamond is a GIA-certified diamond with 1.02-carat weight and SI2 clarity. This magnificent gem has a square shape that is a combination of cushion and princess cut. Equally stylish and elegant, orange-brown diamonds like this one are quite rare to find.

This precious diamond offers outstanding durability and brilliance at every angle. It owes its lovely features to its several facets found on its crown and pavilion, giving the stone an immense brilliance and fire. It makes a perfect choice for a diamond engagement ring with impressive radiance. 

Recently, football star Patrick Mahomes proposed to his partner, Brittany Matthews, during a Super Bowl ceremony, where he presented a radiant-cut diamond in a pavé split-shank band. This piece is certainly a great design inspiration if you are looking for a lovely setting to incorporate a brown diamond stone. 

ProsCons
Stands out when worn
Looks smaller when viewed from above
No pointy edges
High brilliance

#8. 0.29-Carat Light Brown Oval Diamond by Blue Nile

0.29-Carat Light Brown Oval Diamond by Blue Nile

Specifications:

  • Carat Weight: 0.29 carats
  • Shape: Oval
  • Color: Light brown
  • Clarity: VVS2
  • Polish: Good
  • Measurement: 4.85 x 3.40 x 2.21 mm 

During a Comic-Con Marvel Panel, Scarlett Johansson was spotted wearing a massive 11-carat brown diamond engagement ring. It appears to be an oval or oblong-shaped diamond with a brown, smokey tone, which foregoes the traditional celebrity engagement stone. This diamond is said to be around $250,000 to $400,000 in value. 

If you dig this lovely style, you may consider getting the 0.29-Carat Light Brown Oval Diamond by Blue Nile as the center stone for your engagement ring. This diamond has a unique light brown hue with a subtle lemony-like tone and a lively color saturation. Another standout feature of this gem is that it is full of luster and brilliance at every angle. 

This light brown diamond has a slender body with a lovely, elongated look. If you like a round brilliant-cut diamond but want something with more character, this oval brown diamond makes a great choice. Plus, it also priced lower than other diamond cuts. 

ProsCons
Unique brown tone
Oval-cut diamonds have a subtle bowtie effect
Eye-catching shape
Extremely brilliant
Very lively color

#9. 0.70-Carat Fancy Yellowish Brown Round Diamond by James Allen

0.70-Carat Fancy Yellowish Brown Round Diamond by James Allen

Specifications:

  • Carat Weight: 0.70 carats
  • Shape: Round
  • Color: Fancy yellowish-brown
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Polish: Excellent
  • Measurement: 5.52 x 5.48 mm

French-Swiss actress Laetitia Dosch graced the 2019 Cannes Film Festival 2019 while wearing a showstopping choker necklace. She was wearing a lacework of white, cognac, and brown diamonds around her neck from Chopard’s Red Carpet necklace collection. It was conceptualized by Chopard’s artistic director Caroline Scheufele, inspired by roaring twenties fashion. 

Look like a dashing celebrity just like Laetitia Dosch by getting yourself an equally stunning brown diamond. The 0.70-Carat Fancy Yellowish Brown Round Diamond by James Allen is a terrific choice for a diamond necklace. It has a very subtle brown color that doesn’t command too much attention. 

A round brilliant-cut diamond like this one offers an excellent light and color performance. Not only that, it is one of the most versatile cuts, making it easier for you to incorporate it in any jewelry setting.

ProsCons
Very brilliant and sparkly
Very mainstream shape
One-of-a-kind luster
Rich brown color

#10. 0.28-Carat Brown Cushion Cut Diamond by Blue Nile

0.28-Carat Brown Cushion Cut Diamond by Blue Nile

Specifications:

  • Carat Weight: 0.28 carats
  • Shape: Cushion
  • Color: Brown
  • Clarity: SI2
  • Polish: Good
  • Measurement: 3.85 x 3.40 x 2.31 mm

Looking for an equally unique shape and color for an engagement ring? The 0.28-Carat Brown Cushion Cut Diamond by Blue Nile has a soft brown color weighing at 0.28 carats with SI2 clarity. This lovely gem has the closest features to a round diamond, but with curved edges.

This gem looks best when mounted on a white gold or platinum setting to showcase and enhance its brown color.  It is also significantly lower than other cuts.

Indian actress Priyanka Chopra was seen sporting a cushion-cut diamond engagement ring set. The piece made an eye-catching appearance on the actress’ finger, allowing her to showcase more of her beauty.

ProsCons
Hides inclusions and blemishes wellLook smaller when seen from above.
A very lovely contemporary look
May feature a bowtie

Top Pick for Best Brown Diamonds: 0.65-Carat Fancy Yellow Brown Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen

The demand for fancy-colored diamonds has increased significantly in recent years. Instead of settling with colorless crystals, jewelry buyers are actively seeking out unique-looking colored diamonds. When a celebrity sets the trend for a colored diamond, no doubt that the public, including their fans, will follow suit. 

While several diamond varieties are expensive and extremely valuable, brown diamonds are one of the least popular. Although these chocolate-colored gems are not up to the mark of many jewelry lover’s standards, they still make a stunning and affordable jewelry piece. 

This diamond buying guide has included some of the best brown diamonds seen among celebrities. These people have brought plenty of great publicity to a brown diamond’s beauty. While everything looks stunning and unique, the 0.65-Carat Fancy Yellow Brown Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen is the top pick for the best brown diamonds. 

This precious stone from James Allen is simply breathtaking. It is the perfect piece to complete almost any jewelry ensemble. It is graded by the GIA that showcases a rich chocolate hue and unparalleled brilliance. It is quite rare to spot a brown-colored diamond with properly-cut facets and a noticeable brown hue. That is why this valuable gem is a great find for diamond collectors.

Another great feature of this diamond is its one-of-a-kind color intensity. Its shape also helps in enhancing its color at every angle. Plus, it gives off a vintage look, perfect for any vintage-inspired engagement ring setting. 

Brown diamonds are sophisticated and elegant. All the brown diamond selections included in this buying guide can make beautiful statement pieces for those who want a natural, warm tone. Companies like James Allen and Blue Nile provide high-resolution imageries so you can buy with great confidence. 


Best Brands for Brown Diamonds

When buying brown diamonds, remember to purchase only from a trusted, reputable seller. Since brown diamonds are quite rare, finding them at local jewelry stores may be difficult due to inadequate options. Today, searching online for diamonds is a great way to find more options at better prices. Two of the best examples are Blue Nile and James Allen.

Blue Nile

Known as the leading online diamond jewelry vendor, Blue Nile is a great option to look for brown diamonds. Mark Vadon, Blue Nile’s founder, established the company in 1999, following his unsatisfying search for an engagement ring. He recognized that many are often intimidated and overwhelmed by traditional jewelry shopping. From there, he got his inspiration by establishing a new jewelry brand online.

Mark Vadon acquired Internet Diamonds and improved the website, which later earned a new brand name called Blue Nile. The company was based on the idea of bringing innovation to the diamond shopping experience by offering high-quality pieces at compelling values and prices. They also offer unique online tools by sharing diamond informational articles while allowing buyers to shop at their own pace.

Today, Blue Nile offers thousands of fine jewelry pieces and certified diamonds at competitive prices. They also provide unique designer jewelry made from quality standards.

James Allen

Since 2006, James Allen has completely changed the way people shop for jewelry. The company was initially called dirtcheapdiamonds.com, one of the first successful diamond dealers online led by a couple in 1998.

In 2005, the website went through a major rebranding, where they began to adopt a new sophisticated image along with the new brand name called James Allen. It was only a few years when James Allen became of the largest online diamond jewelry dealers worldwide. Their main purpose is to offer customers the largest online inventory of quality diamonds at the best price and value. 

Today, James Allen is known as the first jewelry website to use the 360° Diamond Display Technology, where they feature over 200,000 conflict-free diamonds in a 3D and magnified image. They are also known for offering real-time diamond inspection services and hundreds of customizable jewelry styles. 


Features to Consider When Buying Brown Diamonds (Buyer’s Guide)

Like any fancy-colored diamond, brown diamonds come in different color intensities and are graded in different ways. Read below and learn how to evaluate a brown diamond. 

Hue

Brown diamonds come in many colors, where darker stones are considered more valuable and popular. When talking about hue, it refers to a diamond’s secondary colors. One example is the champagne diamond with brown and yellowish tints.

Tone

The tone indicates how dark or light a diamond is. Cognac diamonds have a much darker tone, while champagne diamonds are lighter. The most valuable stone has a darker tone.

Saturation

Saturation tells the color intensity of a diamond. It also has a similar grading with the tone, where the higher the saturation, the more valuable it is. Color grading is measured using a C1 to C7 scale. The lowest is a light champagne color (C1-C2), while the highest is a cognac diamond with a dark brown saturation (C7).

Clarity

Unlike colorless diamonds, clarity is not a significant factor to consider when buying colored diamonds. Fancy-colored diamonds do a great job of hiding flaws and inclusions than colorless ones. Since brown diamonds are quite dark, they can hide flaws and blemishes well.

What may look like a glaring flaw in a colorless diamond would be entirely invisible for a brown diamond. Still, you must ensure that the brown diamond should be eye-clean with no noticeable inclusions.

Carat

Carat weight greatly affects a diamond’s price as it exponentially increases in weight. This fact applies to all diamonds, including brown. It means that a one-carat brown diamond is more expensive than two half-carat brown diamonds.

If you are looking for the best value for money, remember that carat refers to a diamond’s weight and not the size. You can purchase a single stone under one carat with no noticeable variation but with a considerable price difference. 

Cut

The cut has different advantages for colorless and colored diamonds. It can enhance a diamond’s brilliance or intensify its color.  Brown diamonds are challenging to cut due to their crystalline structure. When a diamond is properly cut, it can bring out a diamond’s true beauty.

Fancy shapes are the best ways to showcase colored diamonds. They help bring out a diamond’s best color than a traditional round brilliant cut.


Conclusion

In the jewelry market, brown diamonds have increased in popularity due to jewelers’ ingenious marketing tactics and high-profile personalities like Hollywood celebrities. These people flaunted their jewelry pieces from the red carpet to the world stage.

Brown diamonds are a great budget alternative to fancy-colored diamonds. They are affordable, more abundant, and make a beautiful center stone. This article has taken a look at the various types of brown diamonds from James Allen and Blue Nile. They are stunning and unique pieces that can complete any jewelry ensemble.

The 0.65-Carat Fancy Yellow Brown Cushion Modified Diamond by James Allen is the top pick for the best brown diamonds. It is a breathtaking brown diamond with an eye-catching rich chocolate hue and unparalleled brilliance. Graded by GIA, this diamond has properly-cut facets and a noticeable brown hue, making this gem is a great find for diamond collectors.

Another great feature of this diamond is its one-of-a-kind color intensity. Its shape enhances its color at every angle. Plus, it gives off a vintage look, perfect for any vintage engagement ring setting. Scarlet Johansson, Rihanna, and Lizzo are some popular celebrities that have brought plenty of great publicity to a brown diamond’s beauty.

Brown diamonds are simply sophisticated and elegant. All the brown diamond selections included in this buying guide can make eye-catching and elegant statement pieces for those who want a natural, warm tone for their jewelry. You can trust reputable online jewelers like James Allen and Blue Nile to provide high-resolution imageries so you can buy with great confidence.


FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

Do synthetic brown diamonds exist?

Brown diamonds are the most abundant and affordable among all fancy-colored diamonds. As a result, finding natural brown diamonds at competitive prices is surprisingly easy. There are also cheaper alternatives like synthetic brown diamonds. However, they are not as common as other expensive colored diamond varieties. 

If you plan to own a synthetic brown diamond, remember that they are not considered fake diamonds and are not of lesser quality as many people erroneously believe. They are real diamonds but lab-created, formed through an artificial procedure, contrary to the geological process on which natural diamonds are made.

How do brown diamonds are priced?

Brown diamonds are one of the most affordable varieties of all fancy-colored diamonds. The color intensity greatly affects its price and value the most. The most expensive variety of brown diamonds are the darker ones with cognac color (C6-C7). Meanwhile, lighter stones are cheaper and very abundant. 

Brown diamonds can be more affordable than a colorless diamond with the same size and shape. A brown diamond’s price varies according to the color and carat weight of a specific stone. When a 1.05-carat colorless diamond is compared to a 1.06-carat cognac diamond, the colorless variety is more expensive than the brown diamond variety. 

Where are brown diamonds sourced?

Brown diamonds are found worldwide, including South Africa and the well-known Argyle mine in Australia. In truth, the Argyle mine is the world’s largest producer of brown diamonds. Its continuous production help transform this dull-colored diamond into a must-have gem through a creative market technique. 

The mine gave a new name to the brown diamond by calling it “champagne diamond,” giving it a classy and sophisticated image. The new concept was immediately adopted in the jewelry market, and brown diamonds began to be seen as romantic-colored stones. It also earned other names, such as cognac diamonds and chocolate diamonds.

Related Resources:

Learn More in Our Related Articles

Shop Online to Save

james allen
james allen reviews

OUR #1 RATED ONLINE JEWELRY STORE

james allen
james allen reviews

Shop Online to Save

james allen
james allen reviews