Top 10 Best Anniversary Rings | 2021 Reviews + Guide

Celebrating a wedding anniversary is indeed one of the greatest milestones in a married couple’s life. More often, husbands look for the perfect anniversary gift for their wives that will serve as a symbol of the beautiful moments they’ve shared and the years they have accomplished together. It includes diamond anniversary rings, an elegant piece fitted for a lady’s taste.

An anniversary ring is a jewelry piece that commemorates special milestones in marriage. They often come with an enduring gold band adorned with multiple gemstones or diamonds. As the name sounds, anniversary rings are often given during major anniversaries, when a couple celebrates silver, gold, and platinum anniversary, but they can also be given at any time.

Unlike engagement rings and wedding bands, anniversary rings tend to be more contemporary. In this case, antique and vintage rings may be an ideal option. Ideally, anniversary rings consist of multiples stones. They come in a variety of settings, depending on the chosen style. 

This buying guide will give you a rundown of the best anniversary rings offered by two leading online diamond jewelry retailers: Blue Nile and James Allen. You will also get to know each of the latest styles included in the product review, best jewelry brands, and key features to consider when buying anniversary rings. 

Read this article and consider the following options before you select the best anniversary ring. 

Top 10 Best Anniversary Rings Reviewed

  1. Riviera Pavé Sapphire and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile – Best Overall
  2. Seven Stone Channel Set Diamond Anniversary Ring by James Allen – Best Value
  3. French Pavé Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile – Editor’s Choice
  4. Seven Stone Shared Prong Diamond Anniversary Ring by James Allen
  5. Garland Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile
  6. Half Bezel Set Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen
  7. Petite Twist Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile
  8. Pave Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen
  9. Sleek Diamond Dome Eternity Ring by Blue Nile
  10. Shared Prong Contour Ruby and Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen

#1. Riviera Pavé Sapphire and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile – Best Overall

Riviera Pavé Sapphire and Diamond Ring in 14k White Gold (1.5mm)

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 0.10 carats
  • Metal: 14k white gold 
  • Quantity: (10) sapphires, (9) diamonds
  • Setting: Pavé setting
  • Color: (medium-dark blue) sapphire, (I) diamonds
  • Clarity: SI2

Not a fan of colorless diamonds? Are you looking for an exciting variation for a pavé-set diamond ring? Blue Nile combines two of the toughest gemstones in the jewelry market: sapphire and diamonds. The Riviera Pavé Sapphire and Diamond Ring feature an alternating pavé set of blue sapphires and diamonds in a 14k white gold shank. 

Equally delicate and brilliant, this stackable anniversary ring is crafted in a petite design that doesn’t look too flashy and attention-grabbing. It makes a perfect band for women born in September with a sapphire birthstone. Due to its low-key presence, you can easily pair it with almost any outfit.

You can get this ring with two other colored gemstones: pink sapphire and ruby. It is also available in platinum if you want a sturdier ring. This anniversary ring comes in a variety of sizes and only costs $790. It can go as low as around $553 when on sale.  

ProsCons
Goes well with an engagement ring and wedding band
Not suitable on large fingers
Bright deep blue sapphire stones
A bit smaller than advertised
Very dainty design

#2. Seven Stone Channel Set Diamond Anniversary Ring by James Allen – Best Value

Seven Stone Channel Set Diamond Anniversary Ring by James Allen

 

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 1.50 carats
  • Metal:14k yellow gold
  • Number of Diamonds: 7
  • Setting: channel set
  • Color: H-I
  • Clarity: SI

Celebrate anniversaries the most brilliant way with James Allen’s diamond rings. The Seven Stone Channel Set Diamond Anniversary Ring features seven round brilliant-cut diamonds arranged in a single row and half the ring’s band. It is fixed in a sleek 14k yellow gold band for a very sleek appearance.

Classic in design, this elegant ring has small grooves to keep the diamonds in place and secured. The diamonds create a dazzling row that’s flush with the shank while set closely together inside its grooves. This type of setting adds visible sparkle and style to a diamond ring. It also draws more attention than a solid solitaire band. 

Plus, it’s also easier to find a matching men’s diamond ring for this style. You can find dozens of styles in the same setting. You can get this ring for $5,720 at James Allen’s website. 

ProsCons
Looks great as a standalone ringLess gemstone visibility
Very large and sparkly diamondsSlightly hard to clean
Heavy gold band

#3. French Pavé Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile – Editor’s Choice

French Pavé Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 1 carat
  • Metal: 950 platinum
  • Number of Diamonds: 24 – 28 (depends on ring size)
  • Setting: pavé setting
  • Color: H
  • Clarity: VS2

Feel like a queen with this sparkly piece from Blue Nile. The French Pavé Diamond Eternity Ring features an entire circle of round brilliant-cut diamonds arranged neatly in enduring platinum. The endless sparkle of its dainty design makes it a perfect wedding or anniversary ring. This ring has a comfort-fit style so that you can wear it 24/7 without the bumpy feeling. 

Combining diamond and platinum in one jewelry piece makes an extremely durable diamond ring. You don’t have to worry about falling stones or eventual misshaping since it is made of the most durable material according to the jewelry industry’s standards. 

This diamond ring is lined with small diamonds along its entire shank. Each stone is held in place with metal prongs, creating a line of continuous sparkling diamonds. This type of setting adds beauty and extra sparkle for a wedding or anniversary ring. 

ProsCons
Goes well with small, thin fingersA lot smaller than the picture
Pairs well with a solitaire ringLooks small on bigger hands
Simple yet elegantProngs run against clothing
Reasonable price

#4. Seven Stone Shared Prong Diamond Anniversary Ring by James Allen

Seven Stone Shared Prong Diamond Anniversary Ring by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 1.50 carats
  • Metal: 14k yellow gold
  • Number of Diamonds: 7
  • Setting: shared prong set
  • Color: H-I
  • Clarity: SI

Every woman certainly fancies a large diamond for her ring. But what if you got seven of them? The Seven Stone Shared Prong Diamond Anniversary Ring gives you the ultimate brilliance you have never seen before. It features seven round brilliant-cut diamonds set in a contemporary and eye-catching anniversary ring. 

This diamond ring comes with bigger melée stones arranged in a shared prong setting. Each stone shares a set of prongs along with the ones sitting next to it. Since it has less visible metal, more light passes through each diamond, giving an added sparkle. 

If yellow gold is too outdated for you, James Allen allows you to pick other precious metals for this piece, including 14k white and rose gold, 18k white and yellow gold, and platinum. With its 1.50 carat weight, you can guarantee that it will give you an incomparable sparkle at every angle. 

ProsCons
Available in six other metalsA little pricey
Very brilliant stones
ALSO READ:  Champagne Diamonds: What You Should Know [2021]

#5. Garland Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile

Garland Diamond Eternity Ring in Platinum (2.5 ct. tw.)

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 2.50 carats 
  • Metal: 950 platinum
  • Number of Diamonds: 39 to 45 (depends on ring size)
  • Setting: common prong setting
  • Color: H
  • Clarity: VS2

The most glamorous diamond ring is sure to light up and dazzle anyone. The Garland Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile is a masterfully crafted diamond eternity ring that is elegant in form and delicate in design. It features brilliant round diamonds arranged into a contemporary garland design. This piece will certainly captivate anyone who lays their eyes on it as it radiates with its high-quality diamonds from Blue Nile. 

This diamond ring creates a magnificent impression of flower garland with its cluster of tiny diamonds in a common prong setting. This setting has small metal prongs positioned on either side of the diamonds holding each stone by their girdle. It’s a widely used setting for round brilliant-cut diamonds as it produces a shimmering trail of stones with little space in between. 

You can get this dazzling piece at $5,890 at Blue Nile. Due to its intricate design, this piece goes well as a standalone ring. No need to add stackable rings for extra sparkle.

ProsCons
Equally as good as luxury retailers like Tiffany
Misshapes after a while
Just enough shine and not too flashy
Sparkly clean and unique
Comfortable to wear

#6. Half Bezel Set Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen

Half Bezel Set Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 1.05
  • Metal: 14k white gold
  • Number of Diamonds: 30
  • Setting: bezel set
  • Color: G-H
  • Clarity: VS2-SI1

Bezel set diamond rings are known for their unmatched perfection. The Half Bezel Set Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen features a row of round brilliant-cut diamonds arranged in a half-bezel setting. Its fancy design certainly captures its beauty as it highlights the diamonds’ brilliance and fire. 

This anniversary diamond ring uses a custom-made thin metal rim that holds the tiny diamonds inside its shank. The metal rim surrounds the diamonds’ outer part, keeping them protected and secure while showcasing their beauty. Unlike prong settings, which tend to be the most delicate ring setting, a bezel-set completely encircles the diamonds to keep them secure and provide a sleek, modern appearance as well. 

This ring costs $1,462 on James Allen’s website under Women’s Eternity rings. It comes in three different metals, including white gold, yellow gold, and rose gold. 

ProsCons
Wide range of available ring size
Diamonds appear smaller due to the setting
Secure bezel settingBrilliance is less prominent
Relatively cheaper

#7. Petite Twist Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile

Petite Twist Diamond Eternity Ring in Platinum (1/5 ct. tw.)

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 0.20 carats
  • Metal: 950 platinum
  • Number of Diamonds: 40/44 (depends on ring size)
  • Setting: pavé setting
  • Color: H
  • Clarity: VS2

Twist eternity rings are a perfect way to represent your eternal love for your lifetime partner. One example is the Petite Twist Diamond Eternity Ring by Blue Nile, a perfect wedding or anniversary ring that features two intertwining bands, including solid platinum and micropavé set diamonds. It comes with 40 pieces of round brilliant-cut diamonds that will surely give off incredible sparkle. 

Like other diamond rings in Blue Nile’s anniversary ring collection, this setting looks outstanding. The dazzling micropavé-set diamonds extend along the ring’s entire length, showing off an elegant statement. Equally classic, elegant, and undeniably beautiful, this diamond eternity ring is a great choice if your wife wants something that comes with plenty of sparkles. 

You can get this ring for $1,350 and can go as low as $945 during special discount offers. You can pick from four different precious metals, including platinum and 14k rose, white, and yellow gold. 

ProsCons
Perfectly complements an engagement ring.
Not available in larger carat size
So much sparkle and characterWay too petite
Suitable for slim fingers
Too thin band
Quality craftsmanship

#8. Pave Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 0.26 carats
  • Metal: 14k yellow gold
  • Number of Diamonds: 38
  • Setting: pavé set
  • Color: F-G
  • Clarity: VS2-SI1

If simplicity is your priority, then this dazzling offering from James Allen will sweep you off your feet. The Pave Diamond Eternity Ring is a classic piece that will certainly dazzle across your finger for all of eternity. It comes with 38 pieces of tiny brilliant diamonds set in an enduring 14k yellow gold band. This type of ring is ideal to be worn along with fashionable stackable bands to bring out its sparkle. 

This ring is a classic favorite for diamond rings, where the entire shank is filled with small diamonds. The stones are held secured in place with metal prongs to create an impression of a continuous line of sparkling diamonds. This type of ring is a perfect choice for someone with an elegant yet sophisticated style. Its intricate details add grandeur and depth to its appearance. 

This ring only costs $1,540 at James Allen’s Women’s Eternity rings section. It also comes with multiple precious metals to complement your style. 

ProsCons
Perfect for slim and small fingers
The ring is almost unnoticeable
Available in six other metalsToo thin and small
ALSO READ:  Top 10 Best 9 Carat Diamond Rings | 2021 Reviews + Guide

#9. Sleek Diamond Dome Eternity Ring by Blue Nile

Sleek Diamond Dome Eternity Ring in 18k White Gold- H/VS2 (2 ct. tw.)

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 2 carats
  • Metal: 18k white gold
  • Number of Diamonds: 91-112 (depends on ring size)
  • Setting: prong
  • Color: H
  • Clarity: VS2

Dome rings are one of the most eye-catching designs for diamond rings. They are encrusted with tiny diamonds that run half of the ring or its entire length. One example is the Sleek Diamond Dome Eternity Ring from Blue Nile. It exhibits a thick row of sparkling round diamonds in an enduring 18k white gold to achieve a dynamic sparkle. 

This incredible diamond dome ring from Blue Nile features two-carat diamonds that give off an incredible presence. With its prong-set diamonds, this stunning diamond anniversary ring will certainly command attention from every angle. 

You can bag this statement anniversary ring for $4,480, but you can wait for special discounts at Blue Nile to fish for larger discounted offers. 

ProsCons
Very noticeable presence
It cannot be resized
Plenty of diamondsSlightly expensive

#10. Shared Prong Contour Ruby and Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen

Shared Prong Contour Ruby                         Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen

Specifications: 

  • Average total carat: 0.65 carats
  • Metal: 14k white gold
  • Quantity: (12) rubies, (12) diamonds
  • Setting: shared prong
  • Color: (red) rubies, (F-G) diamonds
  • Clarity: (fine) rubies, (VS2-SI1) diamonds

If you want a hint of color for your diamond ring, then a combination of colored gemstones and diamonds is the right match for you. The Shared Prong Contour Ruby and Diamond Eternity Ring by James Allen feature a stunning set of diamond and ruby stones in an open-shared prong-set. This setting contours each gemstone to showcase its incredible brilliance and beauty. 

This ring uses a scalloped setting to protect the diamonds and rubies while allowing more light to pass through for ultimate sparkle. The metal prongs holding the accent rubies and diamonds form a U-shaped cutout underneath the shank, reducing the metal’s appearance. 

Ruby gemstone fans, you can get this ring for only $1,720. You may also check out other gemstone ring selections in James Allen in various colored precious stones. 

ProsCons
A stunning combination of diamonds and rubiesRequires careful handling

Top Pick for Best Anniversary Rings: Riviera Pavé Sapphire and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile

A diamond ring is a heartfelt way to commemorate a wedding anniversary with your partner. Anniversary rings for couples are available in a wide range of settings and styles, where you can pick one that is best suited to your activity level, personal preference, and most of all, your budget. 

Unlike engagement rings and wedding bands, anniversary rings have no fixed tradition when it comes to style. Jewelers offer them in a variety of design that perfectly suits a woman’s taste. This buying guide has included a wide range of options for unique anniversary rings. This way, it will give you an idea of the latest designs sold in the market. 

The Riviera Pavé Sapphire and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile takes the top spot as the best anniversary ring. This ring is a combination of two of the most durable gemstones in the jewelry industry: sapphire and diamonds. Both gemstones are arranged in an alternating pavé-set of blue sapphires and diamonds in a 14k white gold shank. 

This anniversary ring gives off a delicate and brilliant appearance as it is crafted in a petite design that will not overwhelm you. Not only will it serve as a diamond ring, but it also makes a perfect present for women born in September with a sapphire birthstone. Due to its subtle design, you can pair it with any casual wear or formal outfit. 

An anniversary ring is a symbolic jewelry piece used to celebrate special milestones in a marriage. If the top pick doesn’t appeal to you that much, you may consider checking out other selections in this buying guide. They all came from credible jewelers that guarantee the best quality and value for your money. 


Best Brands for Anniversary Rings

Just like buying any fine jewelry, choosing the best anniversary ring for your life partner can be a daunting challenge. You need to find a ring with a unique style to complement your love story as much as possible. Reputable jewelers guarantee that their customers walk away with a perfect jewelry piece that they will treasure for several more years of their marriage. 

Get to know two of the top online diamond jewelry retailers that ensure the best jewelry shopping experience. 

Blue Nile

Blue Nile started in 1999 with a simple vision of transforming the diamond jewelry business. While searching for the perfect engagement ring, Blue Nile’s founder, Mark Vandor, discovered the need to innovate the jewelry shopping experience after getting frustrated with finding a diamond ring. 

While following an online business model, Mark acquired Internet Diamonds and established a new jewelry brand. The company was based on introducing a more convenient way of buying a diamond engagement ring. Years later, Blue Nile has built a strong reputation as a premier specialty retailer of diamond jewelry. 

Blue Nile firmly follows its customer-first philosophy as it provides its customers with straightforward jewelry education, more quality choices, and legendary customer service. They employed the most passionate diamond experts and jewelry staff to help them serve their customers better. 

Today, Blue Nile is known for offering premium jewelry items at the best value and prices through an online shopping experience. Their products and services include fancy-colored diamonds, fine jewelry, diamond consultation, proprietary diamond search, and customizable diamond jewelry. 

James Allen

Established in 2006, James Allen has changed the way how people shop for diamond jewelry. It initially started in 1998 after a couple established an online jewelry website called dirtcheapdiamonds.com.

A few years later, an e-commerce platform called R2Net merged with the company and later rebranded as JamesAllen.com. Since then, James Allen adopted a new marketing strategy by establishing a more sophisticated brand, where they offer diamond jewelry sourced from leading diamond authorities. 

It didn’t take long for James Allen to acquire a new customer base, because ten years later, they became one of the leading online jewelers when it comes to sales. They are also known for their 360° Diamond Display Technology, where they showcase over 200,00 ethically sourced diamonds in a magnified 3D HD. They also offer a 100% money-back guarantee, free FedEx shipping, real-time diamond inspection service, and hundreds of customizable styles. 


Features to Consider When Buying Anniversary Rings (Buyer’s Guide)

Anniversary rings come in a huge range of settings and styles. Choosing one should be according to your activity level, personal preference, and budget. Consider the following options before you decide on the perfect anniversary ring to celebrate your years of marriage.

Three-Stone Ring

One of the most well-known styles for anniversary rings is the three-stone diamond ring. Its popularity stems from its inherent symbolism, where people believe the three gems signify the past, present, and future of marriage life. You can find these rings in various styles to complement your engagement ring and wedding band. You can also choose a different design if you want to use it as a standalone jewelry item.

Diamond Band

A diamond band is a great choice for commemorating a marriage anniversary. Some popular options for this style include the eternity ring and pavé-set diamond ring, which people believe signifies everlasting love. 

No matter which style you prefer, diamond bands are available in different styles that are considered special and meaningful. The style and durability may depend on the ring you choose, but several choices are perfect for women who perform demanding work using their hands. You can find several dazzling rings at various price points, so you can find one that fits your budget.

Gemstone Anniversary Rings

Gemstone rings are another perfect way to celebrate a marriage anniversary. You can find them in a wide range of styles and prices, so make sure you pick the one that matches your budget and personal taste. You should also remember that you should wear a gemstone ring on the same hand as your engagement and wedding ring. You should also pick a  colored gemstone that will match your other jewelry pieces. 

Most of the time, women find it convenient to place their gemstone rings on their right hand to avoid the challenge of matching their diamond rings. 

Anniversary Rings for Him

Nowadays, anniversary rings aren’t only for women. Jewelers offer anniversary rings for men in different styles. The traditional anniversary gift for men is a fancy watch, but others seem to forego that tradition. If your man loves jewelry, you can find several options online, such as men’s designer diamond rings and simple bands that are relatively cheaper.  


Conclusion

Diamond anniversary rings are a great way of commemorating a memorable milestone as a married couple. You and your partner can celebrate the wonderful years you’ve shared by getting yourselves a stunning jewelry piece that will symbolize how much you have accomplished together. 

Since anniversary rings hold a sentimental value, finding the perfect piece can be tough. It would be best to consider which diamond ring your partner will greatly appreciate by understanding their preference and style. 

This buying guide has chosen the Riviera Pavé Sapphire and Diamond Ring by Blue Nile as the best anniversary ring. It is a combination of the most durable gemstones used in jewelry: sapphire and diamond. Both gemstones are nearly arranged in an alternating pavé-set of blue sapphires and diamonds in a 14k white gold shank.

Equally delicate and brilliant, this anniversary ring is carefully crafted in a petite design without overwhelming you. It has a very subtle and low-key style, perfect for a classy and sophisticated look. You can also give it as a present for your partner with a sapphire birthstone. 

Anniversary rings are sentimental jewelry items used to celebrate a given number of marriage years. Purchasing a diamond ring from a reputable jeweler ensures that you get the best selections with an expert’s assistance. Once you have found the perfect anniversary, you should display them with faithful brilliance. 


FAQS (Frequently Asked Questions)

How to wear an anniversary ring?

There is no specific rule about how one should wear an anniversary ring. It doesn’t matter which finger you would like to put it on. Your partner can wear the ring on whichever finger they like and on either hand. Others wear their anniversary ring with their engagement ring and wedding band, while others place the ring on their opposite hand’s ring finger. 

Meanwhile, others choose to leave out their engagement and wedding rings and wear the anniversary ring as a standalone band. You can also trade your wedding ring and put more value toward your anniversary ring. 

Generally, people commonly wear their anniversary ring on the right-hand ring finger beside their pinky. This way, the anniversary rings stand out without taking the attention from the engagement and wedding rings. 

When is the best time to give an anniversary ring?

There are no specific rules on when to present an anniversary ring to your partner. In truth, you are free to give your partner an anniversary gift whenever you feel it’s the right time. Since the practice of giving anniversary rings every year of marriage seem impractical, couples choose to celebrate major wedding anniversaries with an expensive jewelry piece. 

The most common occasions for anniversary rings include the first anniversary, where you celebrate a major milestone as a newlywed couple. There is also the 5th, 10th, 20th, 25th, and 50th anniversaries. Others also give anniversary rings to their wives to welcome a new member of a family. 

What is the difference between eternity and anniversary rings?

At first glance, eternity and anniversary rings may resemble each other. However, eternity rings have diamonds that go on a full circle around its shank, while anniversary rings have diamonds that only appear on the front shank. 

When you look at both rings while wearing them, the two look alike. Plus, anniversary rings commemorate the number of marriage years, while eternity bands symbolize everlasting love. 

However, jewelers no longer adapt to this rule; anniversary rings and eternity rings come in different designs and settings. 

Related Resources:

ALSO READ:  Top 8 Best Earrings for Men | 2021 Reviews + Guide

Shop Online to Save

james allen

Best for Online Shopping

james allen reviews
blue nile logo

Best Selections

blue nile reviews
james allen

Our #1 Recommended Jewelry Store

james allen reviews